Showing posts with label 05/10. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 05/10. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Films: The magnificent Ambersons


This family saga from the 1940s revolves around the central character of George Amberson Minafer, a man who is heir to the Amberson fortune and is soon revealed to be spoiled and conceited to the core. Following George throuh mild social scandal and a hesitant love affair is interesting to begin with, but without any empathy for the main character The magnificent Ambersons (d. Orson Welles) grows increasingly uninvolving, and fizzles out with an attempt, far too late, to make you care for his fate. (05/10)

Saturday, September 26, 2009

TV: Smiley's people


Smiley's people is a six-part drama from the early '80s, adapted from the novel by John Le Carre, and large sections of it are mind-bendingly dull. Many worthy actors, including Alec Guinness, Beryl Reid and Patrick Stewart assemble for a cold war thriller that has Guinness' George Smiley investigating the death of a Russian general on British soil.

It's a promising start. Unfortunately, Smiley's investigation is so drawn-out, so tediously paced, that it literally sent me to sleep. More than once. In one episode, Smiley visits only four potential leads, which means four conversations, four scenes, in a 50 minute episode. Four, twelve-minute, two person conversations between the terse Smiley and his equally downbeat 'people'. I'm prepared to accept that our attention spans may have shortened a little in the last two decades, but this is simply astonishing.

In the last episode everything falls into place and the pace moves from a crawl to a brisk walk. There's an interesting story here, but one that is sadly smothered by the worst visual story-telling I think I've ever seen. (5/10)

Monday, August 24, 2009

Books: The dark heart of Italy


The dark heart of Italy was written by Tobias Jones, who lived in Italy as a journalist for years, and wanted to shed light on the hidden aspects of modern-day Italy that are too easily ignored by those looking only for good food, history, and beautiful landscapes. Jones writes about the Italian obsession with beauty, not as a good thing, but as a cultural imperative to focus on the surface of things and not investigate too deeply. He talks about the soul-crushing bureaucracy, and general sense that a little light fraud is not immoral, but simply a fact of life. And he talks about politics and the rise of Berlosconi (although the book was written ten years ago, everything in it matches up eerily well with the news coming out of the country today).

For parts of the book it seems as though Berlusconi is the direct descendant of Mussolini - that Fascism is alive and well in Italy even now. But the final conclusion is perhaps even more disturbing; Jones's suggestion is that Fascism implies an ethos, a belief, however disgusting, but that Berlusconi believes in nothing at all, and has no motivation other than the personal accrual of power and influence.

All this is fascinating stuff, and it may sound as though I was rather keen on the book. Unfortunately, the way the story is told is quite dry (far from the laugh-a-minute tone that the cover implies), and as interesting as parts of it are, much of the book is a turgid history lesson full of obscure names and places that fail to make much of an impact. Well worth skimming through for the good bits, but quite a bit more editing would have been nice. (5/10)

Saturday, June 27, 2009

Films: Sunshine Cleaning


In Sunshine Cleaning (d. Christine Jeffs), two down-on-their-luck sisters in dead-end jobs decide to start their own business cleaning up after dead bodies. Hilarity ensues. Except that it doesn't, really. This is a black comedy with too much black and not enough comedy and as things for the sisters get worse and worse and then dismally horrible, it's hard to fathom the claim on the poster that this is the "feel-good event of the summer".

Having said that, the performances from Amy Adams and Emily Blunt are heartfelt and moving - it's just the script that doesn't know whether to make you laugh or cry, and in the end does neither. (5/10)

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Books: Trumpet


If you're going to read Trumpet by Jackie Kay, don't read the back of the book, or any reviews, as they will spoil the big surprise. It occurs on page 21, and is probably the best bit.

This is a touchy-feely story about reactions to the death of a loved one, and for pretty much the whole book that's all you get: reactions, and no actions. There's no plot to speak of, and the writing, while getting the job done, has nothing memorable about it - no arresting imagery, no sparkling turns of phrase. Having said that, it does the job of getting under the skins of its various characters, and capturing their pain and anger, very well.

The main characters, a grieving wife, a mixed-up son, are far from original, but they are believable. And the struggles they face in coming to terms with the death, and surprising life, of their husband/father force one to consider the admirable determination some people have to live the life they want to live, no matter the consequences. (5/10)

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Books: The house on the strand


The house on the strand (Daphne Du Maurier) is a novel that's rather hard to classify. Written and set in the late 1960s, it's about a man named Dick who's staying in his old friend's old Cornish house in the country, and waiting for his wife and step-sons to join him. While there, his inventor friend asks him to sample a strange potion that he's been working on, which transports the imbiber back in time to the same part of Cornwall as it was in the Middle Ages. While a story of court intrigue unfolds in the past, Dick becomes ever more obsessed with these long-dead people, and less and less interested in his present day life and relationships.

Unfortunately, the book is hamstrung by the fact that the sections set in the Middle Ages feel as though a rather dull professor is reading out of a history textbook, and as Dick is only able to observe, rather than interract with, the past, I found it difficult to invest in what was happening. Dick's obsession therefore becomes very hard to relate to, and so although the present day stuff is more interesting, the whole novel falls a little flat. Perhaps intended to be a metaphor for experimentation with illegal substances, or a story of a man torn between heterosexual and homosexual impulses, or a simple supernatural thriller, this is a book that simply fails to elicit a strong reaction one way or the other. (5/10)

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Books: The Yiddish Policemen's Union


As much as I enjoy a novelist that revels in the English language, and tend to dislike plainly told tales with unadorned prose, it's possible to go too far the other way. The Yiddish Policemen's Union (Michael Chabon) positively groans under the weight of its metaphors, similes and linguistic flourishes. A coffee maker spits "like a decrepit Jewish policeman after ten flights of steps", hair stands up like "magnetised iron filings", and old men smell "like vitamin B, spray starch, smoked fish". Every thing and every one looks, sounds, smells or feels like two or three other things. Much of this imagery works very well (though I'm still not sure I know what vitamin B smells like), and each sentence, taken on it's own, fills me with admiration for Chabon.

The problem comes with the fact that this is a detective story, a hard-boiled, nuts and bolts detective story, which should be barreling along at a pace, instead of screeching to a halt every other paragraph. It's a plot-driven book, or at least, it should be. The main character is an alcoholic trouble-maker with a chequered past and no respect for authority, just like every other hard-boiled detective ever written. And the supporting cast rarely rise above pulp conventions either.

The story is of a simple murder investigation that leads in unexpected directions, told against the backdrop of an alternative world where the Jewish people were relocated to Alaska in 1940. It's inventive and unusual, and would, I think, have made an excellent novel if only reading it didn't feel like wading through treacle. (5/10)

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Books: Wild swans


Wild swans (Jung Chang) is a baggy, often interminable biography and autobiography of a Chinese woman, her mother and grandmother, which spans about a century of history, and seems to take just as long to read. Chang seems unable to stop herself from detailing every notable incident of her life, and the lives of her parents and grandparents. Before long, this barrage of story snippets and banal details ceases to have any emotional impact whatsoever. I think it's telling that, in talking about Wild swans, most people bring up the barbarous foot binding custom that is the first thing described and thus one of the only parts that stands out.

There is no craft to the writing whatsoever; everything from beautiful countryside to vicious torture is described in the same monotonous prose. And none of the supporting characters (of whom there are a multitude) are given enough time to develop into people you might care about.

Yet, despite all this, it's a book worth reading. Why? Because it tells a story that needs to be heard; the story of the rise of Communism in China, of the euphoria that greeted this new direction for the country, in which the poor and disenfranchised would be looked after, and corruption and exploitation would be banished. Followed, of course, by a gradual descent into nightmare and carnage that rivals the most disturbing horror film. I'll admit that, other than the name Mao Tse-tung, I didn't have the faintest idea of what the country went through in the mid-20th Century. It's utterly astonishing, and horrendous, and like the Holocaust or the Greek-Turkish wars, a real slap in the face to realise that humans have done these things to each other so recently, and that awareness of them is often so lacking.

Could Wild swans have lost two thirds of it's length, and been a better book for it? Yes.
Am I sorry that I struggled through it? Definitely not. (5/10)

Monday, December 22, 2008

Films: Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa


Like most of Dreamworks' 3D-animated output, Madagascar 2 (d. Eric Darnell) is just another collection of funny bits, rather than an attempt to tell a compelling story with characters you care about. The design work is as unattractive and careless as in the first Madagascar, so all that really matters, I guess, is how funny the funny bits actually are.

Very sensibly, the film-makers have devoted a little more time to the supporting characters - the lemur king played by Sacha Baron-Cohen, and the deadly, dead funny troupe of commando penguins. These guys are great whenever they're on screen, but sadly, the majority of the running time still has to focus on the four main characters. Who are, for the most part, unamusing, unlikeable, and dull. (5/10)

Wednesday, December 03, 2008

Films: The pink panther


As a child I would always switch over whenever The pink panther (d. Blake Edwards) came on TV, disappointed once the familiar cartoon character left with the credits and was replaced with boring actors. Having loved Peter Sellers in Dr Strangelove when I saw it more recently, I expected that coming back to The pink panther would be a whole different experience. Unfortunately, it seems that I was right the first time.

The physical comedy from Sellers is amusing in parts, and there are a few good lines, but on the whole this farce, about a duo of jewel theives and an incompetant detective, is pretty dull. Dialogue scenes go on for ever and ever, and the little humour that can be derived from people hiding under a bed when the husband comes home gets old all too quickly. The look of the film is great, so '60s it almost seems like a send-up of the '60s, and the familiar Pink Panther theme is catchy. On the whole though, quite a disappointment. (5/10)

Saturday, October 04, 2008

Books: Trauma


Trauma (Patrick McGrath) is the story of a New York psychoanalyst, a specialist in post-traumatic stress disorder, whose past mistakes and own traumas come back to haunt him. The characters are very precisely drawn; his antagonistic brother, his emotionally intelligent ex-wife, his disturbed girlfriend, and so on; but none of them are particularly interesting or entertaining.

The novel is written in a rather inoffensive style that manages to elicit some vague interest in the outcome, but I'm not really sure what it is for. It isn't particularly suspenseful or dramatic, there are certainly no insights into individual behaviour or modern society, and there's no humour whatsoever. It feels like an attempt to be both psychological thriller and literary, character-driven fiction, but one that fails to be satisfying on either count. (5/10)

Friday, August 22, 2008

Films: Peeping Tom


Peeping Tom (d. Michael Powell) was considered to be filth when it was released in 1960 and seems to have ruined the careers of its director and leading man. It's a story of a man, scarred in childhood, who is obsessed with filming people and their pain and suffering. He murders prostitutes, capturing their terror on celluloid so as to relive it over and over again in the privacy of his den.

Neither as frightening, nor as explicit, as it would have seemed 50 years ago, Peeping Tom nevertheless remains intriguing enough to keep one's attention throughout, and Karlheinz Bohm is satisfyingly creepy in the leading role. (5/10)

Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Books: Tales from Ancient Egypt


Tales from Ancient Egypt (Joyce Tyldesley) is a collection of stories, some about gods, some about men, some true, some fiction, from Ancient Egypt. They have been adapted by the author for the modern reader, removing the repetition and glossing over the inevitable gaps in the narrative, where possible. Unfortunately this still leaves a number of tales that are missing the beginning, or more distressingly the end. One of the most enjoyable tales in here, about a doomed prince who knows he will die by dog, snake or crocodile and does everything possible to avoid his fate, is an uncomplicated, involving story that frustratingly gets cut off just prior to the climax.

The creation myths and stories of warring gods are the highlight of the book, although even these come across as muddled and a little unsatisfying. Certainly there is nothing in here to rival The Epic of Gilgamesh and so it's unsuprising that they haven't survived in popular consciousness nearly as well. Perhaps the greatest value is not in the stories as stories, but firstly as a window into the concerns and lifestyles of these ancient peoples, and secondly as an illustration of how many fairytales and biblical parables have their roots thousands of years earlier than one might expect. (5/10)

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Books: The portrait of Mrs Charbuque


The portrait of Mrs Charbuque (Jeffrey Ford) is a novel that's extremely difficult to categorise. Set in New York in the late 19th Century it follows a painter, Piambo, who is disillusioned with his work, involving as it does the production of an endless stream of falsely flattering portraits for the rich and vain. Then, approached by a blind butler, Piambo is commissioned to paint the mysterious Mrs Charbuque, with the promise of a princely remuneration on the proviso that Piambo never be allowed to lay eyes on his model, only to converse with her, hidden behind an opaque screen. His curiosity piqued, the painter jumps at the chance.

What follows is a story that weaves together the eponymous lady's fantastical childhood, the psychological disintigration of our heroic painter, and a murder mystery founded on an ancient poison. The whole thing sounds wonderfully arcane and gothic when summarised in this way, full of the potential for Gaiman-esque goodness, but keeping a grip on these implausible threads requires a skilled, engaging author, and Ford, sadly, is not up to the task.

The writing is thin and hystrionic, and a reasonably strong start deteriorates as the book wears on, to end up reading like a bad thriller rolled up with the worst sort of boddice-ripping romance. A number of intriguing and inventive ideas are let down by a writing style that fails to elicit more than a shrug of mild disinterest. (5/10).

Sunday, June 01, 2008

Films: Dead Poets' Society


I wonder if Dead Poets' Society (d. Peter Weir) is a film that struck a particular chord at the time it was released, or perhaps it taps into a feeling of naive teenage rebellion, which fades over time, but leaves a nostalgic glow in anyone who sees the film early on in life... Whatever the reason for the film's high standing, viewing it for the first time now is a disappointing experience.

It's bad enough to have to swallow the idea that a group of cynical, exuberant, sexual young men would consider reading poetry in a cave to be the height of excitement and daring, but that this love of literature would lead a boy to the extreme actions at the culmination of the film is utterly preposterous. When the grand climax involves nothing more exciting than a class of kids standing on their desks it becomes clear that some fine acting from Robin Williams, and the rest of the young cast, can't save this watery, bland, unconvincing movie. (5/10)

Friday, May 30, 2008

Books: The kingdom of the Hittites


The kingdom of the Hittites (Trevor Bryce) is a comprehensive, not too dry account of the birth of the Hittite people of ancient Anatolia, their various kings, political and military adventures, and eventual destruction. Although not overburdened with the academic references or wranglings over veracity that can make reading ancient history a chore, the book certainly doesn't have the dramatic feel of, say, Joyce Tyldesley's work. It's also a bit too long, considering that there is no discussion whatsoever of society, arts, religion, architecture, or any of the things that can really bring these accounts to life.

Most interesting are the sections of the book on beginnings and endings, how does a people come to prominence and what eventually brings it down? I find any discussion of the 'Sea People' fascinating, those mysterious forces who seem to have brought the entire Bronze Age Near East to its knees, and there's also a lovely final chapter that tries to unpick the truth behind the Trojan War. Seeing the interrelations between the Hittites and other Near Eastern states is also enjoyable, with the Egyptian showdown at Kadesh proving a centre-piece. All in all, The kingdom of the Hittites remains a decent, though fairly unexciting, account of the period. (5/10)

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

Books: Moon tiger


There is a particular breed of film that people with a certain sensibility flock to see. These films will have long shots of beautiful scenery, purple mountains shrouded in mist, glassy lakes, falling leaves, and as little plot as possible so as not to distract from the lucious photography. Moon tiger by Penelope Lively is the literary equivalent. The prose is assured, and at times poetic, the dialogue is sharp and seemingly portentous, but evidently a story, a theme, or a nuanced characterisation would just get in the way.

The book follows a woman called Claudia through her life, a life bisected by the Second World War, during which she is a reporter on the Egyptian front. Claudia is witty, biting, misanthropic, and relatively unsympathetic, and her co-stars are either just like her, or are utterly dull, soft and unimaginative. The only character to escape these extremes is Tom the soldier, the love of her life, who is a perfect specimen of self-assured, self-depricating manliness. Unfortunately, none of these underwritten characters grow or change over the course of the story, and neither is there any tension, nor unexpected twists within the plot. Moon tiger won the Booker Prize in 1987, and I can only assume that the judges were so won over by the writing that they failed to notice that nothing actually happens. (5/10)

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Films: Tape


Reminiscent of Before sunrise and Before sunset, Richard Linklater's Tape bravely limits itself to three characters talking in a single motel room. It says a lot for the director that such a pared-down film can hold one's attention for ninety minutes, and it does, although unfortunately the story, which remains so compelling for so long, totally fizzles out at the end. Not to mention that Sunrise and Sunset placed their long conversations against the backdrop of two of the most beautiful cities in the world, making the most of their visual medium, as opposed to this, which could just as easily have been a radio-play. (5/10)

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Films: The big sleep


The big sleep (d. Howard Hawks) is a Bogart and Bacall thriller, taken from the novel by Raymond Chandler. Bogart plays detective Philip Marlowe, hired by a rich man to find out what his flighty younger daughter has become mixed up in, but inevitibly falling for her older sister in the end. The two leads do what they do best and have some nice dialogue to work with but are hobbled by a meandering, convoluted plot that is no fun at all to figure out. (5/10)

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Books: Papillon


Four months after I began it, I finally finished reading Papillon (Henri Charriere). This story of a Frenchman sentenced to life imprisonment in the penal colonies of South America is not dull, or uninteresting, by any means. Many of Papillon's anecdotes and escape attempts make for good reading, and paint a picture of a man living by a code of honour, determined to keep fighting for his freedom if it takes forever.

The problem, for me, was the lack of any sense of progression or structure, the absence of plot threads or character journeys weaving together towards a climax, the complete aimlessness of the book.
Papillon gets captured. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon manages to escape.
Papillon gets captured. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon manages to escape.
Papillon gets captured....
There are elements within this memoir that are memorable and reasonably well written, but without an overarching plot or a cast of characters it's too easy to put the book down and not pick it up again for weeks. (5/10)