
Rarely have my feelings about a book taken such a significant turn between the first pages and the last. The butcher boy (Patrick McCabe) tells the story of a young Irish lad, Francie, living in a village near Dublin, back in the 1960s. It's told from Francie's point of view, in a stream-of-consciousness style, lacking commas and speech-marks and grammar. It's full of old Irish turns of phrase, and references to the Dandy, and lovely, innocent, Oirish charm. I hated every horrible grating paragraph... at first.
I'm just not interested in hearing about how, back in the old days, out in the countryside, people were rougher and times were tougher, but in the end everybody looked out for each other and wasn't it all pretty jolly in the end. And that's the book I thought this was going to be, but I couldn't have been more wrong. Without wanting to give too much away, this is a book about neglect, abuse, callousness, obsession, mental illness, and death, lots of death. It's challenging stuff, but absolutely gripping, at times funny, and heart-breaking in the end.
The impressionistic style, which I found so irritating at first, draws you into the warped mind of the protagonist and leaves you unsure which way is up. A difficult technique to get right, those who try often end up producing writing that is murky and obscure, but here, it's handled with wit and flair and clarity. My first assessment was correct in one sense, The butcher boy is indeed a horrible book, but in all the right ways. (8/10)
















































































































