Monday, November 16, 2009

Books: The idea of perfection


Set in a small town in the Australian outback, The idea of perfection (Kate Grenville) is a love story without romance, a tale of the coming together of two people who have given up on love. The characterisation isn't subtle - the three main characters are called Harley Savage, Douglas Cheeseman, and Felicity Porcelain, and you can tell almost everything you need to know about them from their names - but the writing is deft, with a plot that ticks along nicely, and a consistent, cleverly woven theme that explores and celebrates imperfection in all its forms.

Harley and Douglas are damaged characters, flawed, and at times unsympathetic, and it's refreshing to find a story that treats the protagonists as imperfect, but doesn't show this imperfection as driving them apart. Instead it is these insecurities, their hang-ups and idiosyncrasies, that draw the two together; Harley and Douglas aren't "meant for each other", but they are "right for each other", and while the book itself is not perfect, I did end up caring very much about whether the two would find happiness together. (7/10)

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Films: The last king of Scotland


The last king of Scotland (d. Kevin Macdonald) tells the story of a (fictional) Scottish doctor who travels to Uganda in the 1970s and gets brought into the inner circle of the infamous dictator Idi Amin, just as he begins his descent into barbarism. Interesting (for me, as someone born just after these events took place) to get a sense of what went on back then, but there are no real surprises. Most importantly, the character of the doctor doesn't really ring true, and does some pretty astonishingly silly things, just in order to move the story along to its conclusion. The highlight of the film, by far, is Forest Whitaker's performance as Amin, which is frightening and powerful. (6/10)

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Films: The magnificent Ambersons


This family saga from the 1940s revolves around the central character of George Amberson Minafer, a man who is heir to the Amberson fortune and is soon revealed to be spoiled and conceited to the core. Following George throuh mild social scandal and a hesitant love affair is interesting to begin with, but without any empathy for the main character The magnificent Ambersons (d. Orson Welles) grows increasingly uninvolving, and fizzles out with an attempt, far too late, to make you care for his fate. (05/10)

Sunday, November 08, 2009

Films: Fantastic Mr Fox


Here we have Wes Anderson, the smugly esoteric and existential American film-maker, wrestling with the ghost of Roald Dahl, the charmingly eccentric and child-like English author, over the spirit of Fantastic Mr Fox.

Wes Anderson wins hands down. This is not a children's film. It's not even a good grown-up's film, unless you like Anderson's noodly, wishy-washy, robotic style (I don't). If the direction, script and acting weren't enough, any chance of avoiding complete disappointment is scuppered by the decision to animate the story using what appears to be a set of slightly mangy Sylvanian Families. (2/10)

Saturday, November 07, 2009

Films: An affair to remember


An affair to remember (d. Leo McCarey) is apparently considered one of the most romantic movies of all time. It does get off to a very promising start, with Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr meeting on an ocean liner and sparring with each other mercilessly, and flirtatiously, until eventually admitting their mutual desire. The dialogue is sharp and funny, with both parties giving as good as they get. Gradually, though, the banter subsides, to be replaced by pining, and obstacles put in the way of true love, and a lot of standard, mawkish stuff that's been done to death before and since. A good film to snooze to on a Sunday afternoon. (6/10)