Friday, December 28, 2007

Films: Once


Once (d. John Carney) is a simple, low-budget film about an Irish busker and a young émigré from Eastern Europe. The two meet, form a bond, and eventually form a band, in a story that reminded me of Lost in translation. Long, uninterupted musical interludes frame a bittersweet account of unexpected companionship, thwarted by the realities and complexities of life. (8/10)

Saturday, December 15, 2007

Films: The graduate

The graduate (d. Mike Nichols) made the name of the young Dustin Hoffman, and it's easy to see why. He's excellent as the naive, awkward, hesitant university graduate who gets in too deep with an older woman and comes to regret it. Anne Bancroft plays the icy temptress, whose no-nonsense attitude towards her young lover leads to many very funny scenes but eventually turns to scorn. (7/10)

Monday, December 10, 2007

Books: If I told you once


If I told you once (Judy Budnitz) tells the story of four generations of women from a Jewish family originating somewhere in Eastern Europe that emigrates to the US early in the 20th Century. There is an undercurrent of gothic fantasy throughout, particularly in the early sections which are populated by wolves and woodcutters, sinister crones and pale maidens with flowing hair. But the young heroine of these first chapters escapes to New York and begins to mature as we watch her daughter, grand-daughter and great grand-daughter grow to adulthood.

All of these girls begin as very sympathetic characters, but as they grow older something seems to go wrong and negative, even villainous traits emerge. The reader can identify with and cheer on the youngest girl of the family, up until the point where the next youngest comes along. In the New World the goings-on become more realistic, and sadly, a little more dull. There are still flashes of the bizarre: street sweepers who come in the night and take everything away; an ice-cream man who abducts small children; but on the whole the world becomes more mundane. Overall, some lovely, sinister, beautifully written flights of fancy, are undercut slightly by a plot without rhythm or crescendo that circles round and goes nowhere. (7/10)

Tuesday, December 04, 2007

TV: The Sopranos, Season 6 (Part 2)


See my previous post for how much I love The Sopranos. The last nine episodes have drawn a lot of criticism, particularly for the ambiguous resolution (or non-resolution) of Tony Soprano's story. I was crossing my fingers that I wouldn't feel similarly let down, but I have to admit that in the end it wasn't quite all I'd hoped for.

The end of the final episode, to me, was pretty perfect, and shouldn't come as a nasty surprise to anyone who's been watching the show from the start. But those last few episodes, which wrap up some storylines beautifully (Tony's son AJ and his nephew Chris both have fitting send offs), really failed to deliver in other ways. The biggest let-down was the underutlization of Edie Falco as Carmella Soprano. To waste such a talented actor, and a character with so many skeletons still to unearth, is a terrible shame. But a couple of dud episodes and some wasted potential can't do much to dent this series that has put more intelligence and depth into television than any other. (9/10)