
The secret scripture (Sebastian Barry) is a novel whose central thesis seems to be that every narrator is unreliable thanks to the subjectivity of memory, and that therefore, how can we ever trust history?
The story of the book is the story of Roseanne, an Irish woman in her 100s who has spent the latter half of her life detained in an asylum. She writes about her childhood and her father and how they got mixed up in the beginning of the troubles, about her ill-fated marriage, and eventually about the reason for her incarceration. (Anyone who knows anything about the asylums of the early 20th Century can probably guess that reason from the synopsis). As the novel progresses it becomes clear that some of Roseanne's testimony of her life may be faulty, but it's hard to take too much away from that, given her age and circumstance.
The book is partially set during the upheavals in Ireland of the 1920s and 1930s, something I know little about and about which I would be interested to learn. Unfortunately, Barry assumes that the reader understands the background already, or doesn't care to explain it, and so I came away no wiser than I was going in. The story is told without any trace of humour, but rather with a leaden, dreary tone, and to make matters worse, this unexceptional tale concludes with a quite preposterous twist ending. Writing a novel that concerns itself exclusively with character and theme, and then plucking an ending out of the nearest soap opera, seems to betray a lack of confidence on the part of the author. (3/10)
















































































































