Showing posts with label doctor who. Show all posts
Showing posts with label doctor who. Show all posts

Sunday, July 06, 2008

TV: Doctor Who, Season 4


Baring a few one-off specials in 2009, Russel T. Davies' run on Doctor Who comes to an end with Season 4. It's been a great four years, and although Davies himself has been hit-and-miss, his high-points have been outstanding. His greatest achievement was to bring the show back after so long, with special effects and production values and acting talent that easily eclipsed the programme that I grew up with, yet retaining the essence of Doctor Who. The clunkiness, the kitch, the family-friendly horror... for some it's all just a bit too silly, but most people, happily, seem able to embrace the new version as an utterly charming slice of British telly. Just at it always was.

This latest season re-introduced Catherine Tate as Donna Noble, a temping secretary plodding through her life, who, having met the Doctor, can't rest until she finds him again and joins him on his adventures through space and time. To be honest, the quality of the episodes this year hasn't seemed quite as high as the last, and perhaps that is down to Tate. Things get very dark for Donna towards the end, and her resulting distress is played extremely well, but for much of the rest of the season Tate simply falls back on her comedy persona, never quite seeming to fit in with the tone of the show.

The highlights, as with the preceding three years, were the episodes by Stephen Moffat. He knows how to write 'scary', it's true, but he's also easily as witty as anything the new series has to offer, and by far the most complex in his plotting. A real joy to watch, and meaty enough to be worth a second viewing.

The season concludes with a universe-shaking conflict with the evil daleks, bringing all of the Doctor's recent companions together in one climactic showdown. Although, of course, the good guys win and there's even an unexpected romantic twist, the ending is surprisingly downbeat. One character suffers a horrible fate, arguably a fate worse than death, and the Doctor ends as he began: totally alone. A satisfying conclusion were it not for the glaringly obvious absence of Christopher Eccleston, who was clearly intended to appear as the Doctor's previous incarnation. One final fly in the ointment of a season that was fun but never quite as good as it might have been. (8/10)

Saturday, June 30, 2007

TV: Doctor Who, Season 3


Season 3 is by far the most consistently entertaining season of the new Doctor Who, thanks in part to the introduction of the wonderfully likeable Freema Agyeman as Martha Jones, the Doctor's new assistant. Agyeman fits in perfectly, lending just the right notes of enthusiasm and conviction. Also, the quality of the writing is noticably higher, with very few dud episodes (only Shakespeare and the dalek two-parter fall flat), and some really excellent ones. John Smith's doomed romance on the eve of World War One is genuinely emotional, Blink is proper intelligent science-fiction, and John Simm as a completely deranged Master is fantastic fun to watch. (9/10)