Showing posts with label tv. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tv. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 08, 2009

TV: Dollhouse, Season 1


I was always going to have to watch Dollhouse. It's hard to imagine Joss Whedon, the geeky mastermind behind Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Firefly, and Dr Horrible's sing-along blog ever making a show so badly received that I'd decide to give it a miss. But, blimey, was Dollhouse badly received.

The science fiction show, about an underground organisation that sells the services of brainwashed people, programmed to be the perfect lovers, assassins, bodyguards, detectives or anything else the clients desire, was panned in America from day one. Viewing figures were abysmal and the show remained constantly on the verge of cancellation. Imagine my intense surprise and happiness then, when the first season turned out to be really quite decent after all.

Admittedly the weakest of Whedon's shows so far (I think mainly because too many of the characters are too 'normal', too much like the standard cookie-cutter roles that litter US drama), Dollhouse still has more than enough of the inventiveness, thoughtfulness, surrealism and endearing characterisation that sets his work apart. Add to this a constant stream of twists and reversals as the FBI hunt down the shadowy organisation, and the mind-control and false personalities become ever more sinister, and it's really quite hard to figure out why this show didn't do a little better. (8/10)

Wednesday, October 07, 2009

TV: I, Claudius


I, Claudius, produced by the BBC back in the 1970s, often seems to be cited as the high water-mark of television drama, so I've been curious for a while to see what it's like. Perhaps unsurprisingly, it turns out not to be a patch on the best that TV has to offer today.

What did surprise me is that the problem is not with the production values. Everyone talks about the wobbly sets, and the crowd scenes made up of three men with a pitchfork, but this didn't bother me for a moment. The sets are actually very good, and although they mostly get out of showing large crowds, this is done artfully, and is all but unnoticeable.

The problem, as with Smiley's people, is chiefly the pacing. Though not nearly as turgid as the aforementioned spy thriller, there just isn't enough drama or fast-paced dialogue to hold one's attention. There are dozens of classic actors peppered throughout the series (which chronicles the life of the Emperor Claudius of Rome and takes in Augustus, Tiberius and Caligula along the way), but many play their roles as so theatrical and broad that it's difficult to buy into the reality of the scene.

As a bit of a Roman history geek, I was interested enough to follow the series through to the end, but stacked up against The wire, The Sopranos, Battlestar Galactica, or The West Wing, I, Claudius comes off looking old fashioned and more than a little stagy. (7/10)

Monday, September 28, 2009

TV: Battlestar Galactica, Season 4.5


Well, it's over. I can imagine that in twenty year's time a whole generation of geeks will be united by the memory of this summer, spent wondering who the final cylon would turn out to be. Battlestar Galactica finished up with the second part of Season 4, and it was a pretty decent ending. A little slow and ponderous in parts, gripping and fascinating in others. The final episode was action packed, in a way that I was never sure it would be, and also touching, which I did expect, of course.

What's more, the many mysteries raised over the course of the series were revealed in a startlingly spiritual climax. At its best, Battlestar Galactica has always been a show that addressed difficult issues - much of the middle part of the storyline cast the cylons in the role of an occupying force and the humans as an insurgent resistance in a clear, and controversial parallel of the Iraq war. Afterwards, issues of collaboration and of segregation were explored unflinchingly and unsentimentally. And without wanting to spoil too much, the conclusion of the final season hinges on the intervention of the divine in our characters' lives, making the show unequivocally theistic, in a way few are in this sceptical age. Literally a deus ex machina ending.

Beginning with a no-holds-barred mutiny, and finishing up with revelations and Revelation, this turned out to be an absolutely satisfying, fitting, and nail-biting conclusion to Battlestar Galactica. (8/10)

Saturday, September 26, 2009

TV: Smiley's people


Smiley's people is a six-part drama from the early '80s, adapted from the novel by John Le Carre, and large sections of it are mind-bendingly dull. Many worthy actors, including Alec Guinness, Beryl Reid and Patrick Stewart assemble for a cold war thriller that has Guinness' George Smiley investigating the death of a Russian general on British soil.

It's a promising start. Unfortunately, Smiley's investigation is so drawn-out, so tediously paced, that it literally sent me to sleep. More than once. In one episode, Smiley visits only four potential leads, which means four conversations, four scenes, in a 50 minute episode. Four, twelve-minute, two person conversations between the terse Smiley and his equally downbeat 'people'. I'm prepared to accept that our attention spans may have shortened a little in the last two decades, but this is simply astonishing.

In the last episode everything falls into place and the pace moves from a crawl to a brisk walk. There's an interesting story here, but one that is sadly smothered by the worst visual story-telling I think I've ever seen. (5/10)

Friday, August 14, 2009

TV: The wire, Season 5


It's impossible to ignore the fact that the 5th season of The wire, its last season, is also its weakest. Everyone says so, and it's true. But that absolutely mustn't detract from the fact that even a sub-par season of this show is truly amazing. More engaging, more moving, more important than almost anything else on television.

The problems stem from the central storyline of Season 5, which brings a new cohort of characters into the show, using the journalists of the Baltimore Sun newspaper to shed light on what does and doesn't get reported in the decaying cities of America. These characters are entertaining enough, but one in particular is just a little too obviously villainous to sit easily in the world of the Wire, which has always been about shades of grey, rather than black-hats and white-hats. Over in the police department, this lapse in writing is mirrored, as a number of established characters cross over the line of verisimilitude and begin acting like television characters furthering a plot, instead of the utterly believable figures they've been until now.

But enough of that. The fact is that the majority of the cast and storylines we've been following for five years are well served here, with twists and turns that fit beautifully with what's gone before. The way Omar's storyline ends, one of the most popular characters on the show, is so perfect, and would never, ever have played out the same way on any other programme. Every character who's played a major part in the story is returned to, and their resolutions are note perfect. The final episode is certainly the best conclusion to any long-running series that I can think of, which is no mean feat given how hard it is to get an ending right. The bitter and the sweet are perfectly balanced and I find myself watching those closing minutes over and over again, with a smile on my face and a lump in my throat. (9/10)

Friday, July 10, 2009

TV: The thick of it


The thick of it is a short-lived British television comedy that follows an inept Government minister and his run-ins with the party spin doctor. Peter Capaldi steals the show as the vituperative hatchet-man, who terrifies MPs and civil servants alike with his venomous, unforgiving attacks should they step out of line and draw the attention of the press.

Almost the anti-West Wing, The thick of it lifts the curtains on the venality and weasellyness of politics and politicians, and manages to raise a laugh or two in the process. More uncomfortable than funny, perhaps, although Capaldi's creatively sweary put-downs are worth the price of the DVD alone. (6/10)

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

TV: The deal


The deal (d. Stephen Frears) is the first in a trilogy of movies written by Peter Morgan that follow significant events in the life of the British Prime Minister Tony Blair.  Here, Michael Sheen plays Blair and David Morrissey plays Gordon Brown as the two arrive in Westminster and rapidly become close friends.  The film follows them through Labour's repeated disappointments in the 1980s and early '90s, until a chance finally arises for one of them to take control of the party and lead it to victory.  

Obviously we all know what happened, but the fascination is in watching the two men's rise to power, and the gradual souring of their friendship, which eventually turns to rivalry and rancor.   The following film, The Queen, is equally good, and The special relationship, which will wrap up the series, is currently being filmed. (8/10)

Monday, January 26, 2009

TV: Lost, Season 4


To anyone who gave up on Lost during its infuriating first season or disappointing second season... to any UK viewers who gave up after season three was cut short by broadcaster politics... I urge you to give it another go.

The third season brought the sinister 'others' out into the open and into direct conflict with the crash survivors. The plotting tightened up, questions began to be answered, and hope of rescue from the island became a reality. Season 4, however, goes even further. The writers have set an end date, they know where the story is going, and it shows. Gone are the meandering flashbacks and snail-like plot progression of the early years; Season 4 has twists, action and revelations to spare.

Four years in, it's clear that Lost's island is not just a place where strange things happen, it's a sentient being with powers that are still being revealed. Two factions are at war over possession of this magical place, and the survivors of Oceanic 815 are merely innocent bystanders who got caught in the middle. Some will be rescued, some will remain behind, but no one will be free until the island is finished with them. (9/10)

Saturday, December 13, 2008

TV: Shooting the past


Shooting the past is a tv drama, written and directed by Stephen Poliakoff. It tells the story of a massive old photo-archive, housed in a grand manor house and staffed by a small clique of misfits. American developers arrive to turn the house into a conference centre, and the archivists are given an ultimatum: find a new home for their millions of photographs, or chuck them out with the rubbish.

Lyndsay Duncan and Timothy Spall are excellent as the lead archivists; modest, unassuming and unconventional, but passionate and determined, they're rather a lot like the real librarians I've worked with. Liam Cunningham is also convincing as the American businessman, who proves surprisingly sympathetic, but impossible to win round.

While not the most exciting or engaging tv I've come across, there is a lot to like. Poliakoff clearly loves his subjects, and conjures up an air of dusty mystique around the boxes upon boxes of fading sepia images. Above all, this is a celebration of those who remain stubbornly different, those who value the past, and those who fight against the encroaching tides of commercialism and uniformity. (7/10)

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

TV: Battlestar Galactica, Season 4


Season 4 of Battlestar Galactica was a short year, containing only 10 episodes, plus a 90 minute tv movie that fills in some blanks from previous seasons. The show is still going strong and continues to be one of the most realistic, gritty depictions of life lived in outer space ever put to film. It remains just a little too po-faced and portentous for its own good, and the pacing seems less full on than in previous seasons, but there's a very clear sense that the storylines are coming to a head and that the climax is just around the corner.

Tensions escalate as infiltrators within the fleet are revealed, the strange religious conflict between monotheism and polytheism finally comes to the fore, and the search for Earth nears its end. Only a handful of episodes remain for the 5th season, and only time will tell whether the writers have a suitably satisfying denoument up their sleeves. (8/10)

Thursday, October 16, 2008

TV: The wire, Season 4


When I wrote about Season 1 of The wire, I compared it unfavorably to The Sopranos, saying that it failed to so perfectly reflect the concerns and aspirations of the modern middle-class family-man. Of course, that was never the point. The wire is about the forgotten people, the people who never make it to American TV, the poor, worn-down blue-collar workers and criminals, trying to make it on the outskirts of society. The wire is not about understanding yourself, it's about trying to understand the others.

As in Season 2, this season relaxes the focus on the drug war, instead turning attention to the Baltimore school system. Another system that is failing and corrupted and corrupting, like the political world and the police force and the dockworkers' union and the drug gangs that have gone before it.

Four young boys make their way through a school year, trying to work out what they can expect from a future with depressingly limited options. They are played by a stunning set of child actors who sell perfectly the false bravado, the bubbling potential and the deep scars that are part and parcel of growing up on the streets. Meanwhile, all the old characters return, some with very new outlooks on life, and the great, multi-faceted, totally absorbing TV-novel that is The wire continues. (10/10)

Saturday, September 06, 2008

TV: Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, Season 1


Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip is one of a long line of great American tv shows to get cancelled before it could find its audience.

Aaron Sorkin's follow up to The West Wing, Studio 60 should have been much more of a crowd-pleaser. Starring Matthew Perry of Friends and set behind the scenes on a satirical sketch show, rather than in the apparently dry political world of West Wing, it's very hard to see why this didn't take off. My guess is that in tackling the current state of real world US politics head on, and the disconnect between the religious centre and liberal edges of America, Studio 60 managed to alienate an even larger demographic than it's predecessor. Perhaps something to be proud of?

The subject matter aside, it's still a Sorkin production, which means that, true to form, it's also full of the most lovable, flawed, prickly, and incredibly quick-witted characters on tv. (9/10)

Monday, August 04, 2008

TV: The wire, Season 3


In Season 3 of The wire, life on the streets of Baltimore gets downright Shakespearean. The focus this time round moves away from the dock workers of last season and back to the drug-dealers' never-ending fight for turf, and the police's never-ending quest to bring down their criminal conspiracy.

As always, building the case is slow and frustrating and fraught with politics, and the story moves between dozens of perspectives, from addicts to police lieutenants, and from drug kingpins to political campaign advisers. This year, two men stand out from the rest: 'Stringer' Bell, the well-read gang leader, and Lieutenant Caldwin, the idealistic chief of the Western District; parallel figures who fight against the status quo so as to revolutionise how the war on drugs is fought. (10/10)

Sunday, July 06, 2008

TV: Doctor Who, Season 4


Baring a few one-off specials in 2009, Russel T. Davies' run on Doctor Who comes to an end with Season 4. It's been a great four years, and although Davies himself has been hit-and-miss, his high-points have been outstanding. His greatest achievement was to bring the show back after so long, with special effects and production values and acting talent that easily eclipsed the programme that I grew up with, yet retaining the essence of Doctor Who. The clunkiness, the kitch, the family-friendly horror... for some it's all just a bit too silly, but most people, happily, seem able to embrace the new version as an utterly charming slice of British telly. Just at it always was.

This latest season re-introduced Catherine Tate as Donna Noble, a temping secretary plodding through her life, who, having met the Doctor, can't rest until she finds him again and joins him on his adventures through space and time. To be honest, the quality of the episodes this year hasn't seemed quite as high as the last, and perhaps that is down to Tate. Things get very dark for Donna towards the end, and her resulting distress is played extremely well, but for much of the rest of the season Tate simply falls back on her comedy persona, never quite seeming to fit in with the tone of the show.

The highlights, as with the preceding three years, were the episodes by Stephen Moffat. He knows how to write 'scary', it's true, but he's also easily as witty as anything the new series has to offer, and by far the most complex in his plotting. A real joy to watch, and meaty enough to be worth a second viewing.

The season concludes with a universe-shaking conflict with the evil daleks, bringing all of the Doctor's recent companions together in one climactic showdown. Although, of course, the good guys win and there's even an unexpected romantic twist, the ending is surprisingly downbeat. One character suffers a horrible fate, arguably a fate worse than death, and the Doctor ends as he began: totally alone. A satisfying conclusion were it not for the glaringly obvious absence of Christopher Eccleston, who was clearly intended to appear as the Doctor's previous incarnation. One final fly in the ointment of a season that was fun but never quite as good as it might have been. (8/10)

Sunday, June 08, 2008

TV: Battlestar Galactica, Season 3


The new Battlestar Galactica just gets more and more interesting with each passing season. It's a science fiction epic, yes, but with the sort of grimy, hard-bitten, cinematic edge that brings it far closer to Band of brothers or Saving Private Ryan than any television sf that's gone before. It's also a political and religious allegory, with suicide bombings and religious zealots, and the audience on the 'wrong' side.

But most of all it's a story of a brave but jaded group of refugees fleeing for their lives across the stars, a story that grips you hard and barely lets up for a moment. Beginning with a fight for freedom and ending with death, and a revelation of the enemies within, Season 3 ups the ante once more. (9/10)

Thursday, May 08, 2008

TV: Life on Mars, Season 1


I've written previously about how impressed I've been by Life on Mars, which had such a strange premise that I put off watching it for years. Sam Tyler, a police officer from the present, gets knocked unconscious and wakes up in 1972, where he joins the Manchester force and solves crimes alongside the unreconstructed Neanderthal DCI Gene Hunt. Is it science-fiction? A detective show? Both, or neither?

In the end it doesn't matter because so many of the episodes in Season 1 are so wonderfully well-written, witty, surreal and incredibly pacy. Not every episode is unforgettable, but they're all good fun, with Sam trying desperately to work out what's going on, while the supporting cast send up the unenlightened Seventies perfectly. (7/10)

Monday, April 21, 2008

TV: Arrested development, Season 3


Arrested development was a doomed experiment to make an American comedy about unlikeable people, in which you get the joke three seconds after the punchline instead of thirty seconds before. Likened to a live-action Simpsons, the series follows Michael Blooth, the good-hearted son in a family of crooked property developers, as he and they get themselves into increasingly unlikely situations.

A clever script, full of in-jokes and verbal dexterity, delivered by an astonishing cast that could make the obituaries sound funny, make me very sad that this truncated Season 3 is the last we'll see of the Blooths. (9/10)

Monday, April 14, 2008

TV: The wire, Season 2


Season 2 of The wire takes the already complex and sprawling storyline from the first season, and ups the ante. Beginning with characters from every level of two well-developed organisations; the Baltimore police department and the drugs gang it's fighting; the new season brings in a third cohort, members of the Polish dock-workers guild, who interrelate with the existing cast in multiple ways. The web of characters becomes so vast that concentration is required to keep a handle on the plot, but manage to ride along with it and you begin to feel as though you know the city of Baltimore inside and out.

As before, there is a target to bring down, a surveillance operation to set up, and a case to build, slowly and carefully. There are beaurcratic hurdles, numerous set-backs, occasional small victories, and a dramatic, emotional, but very real conclusion. This is a dark and grimy world that's being explored, full of drug addicts covered in sores and police whose personal lives are in tatters, but the show manages to find much more humour than in Season 1, which is a blessing and does a lot to elevate the programme into something truly great. (9/10)

Thursday, March 27, 2008

TV: Ashes to ashes, Season 1


I haven't seen all of Life on Mars, but many of the episodes I have seen have been really, really impressive. Ashes to ashes is the sequel, moving the action from 1970s Manchester to 1980s London and putting in Keeley Hawes as the lead, but keeping the masterful, leonine Philip Glennister in place as the cocky, growling, politically incorrect DCI Gene Hunt. The concept is a strange one: a police officer from the present gets knocked unconscious and is seemingly transported, by their subconscious mind, twenty or thirty years into the past. What results is a big, ballsy cop-show, with a dash of surrealism and a whole lot of culture shock for the hero, who has to adjust to outdated social mores that prove surprisingly distant from their own.

Both shows are good fun, and Gene Hunt is an instant icon; completely in love with himself, offensive and surley, yet immensely appealing and watchable. He insults people with style and fights or flirts without the slightest regard for propriety. Fantastic. Unfortunately though, there isn't much else that's really great in Ashes to ashes. Some people have blamed Keeley Hawes, others the change of era. But if you watch Life on Mars and Ashes to ashes back to back it's clear that the real problem is the scripts. There are episodes of Mars that are among the best hours of television I've seen, with more plot and excitement than many feature films. The sequel is just limp and lazy in comparison. The dialogue remains sharp, but the plots are generally uninspired and uninvolving. It's a real shame; Gene deserves better. (6/10)

Friday, March 21, 2008

TV: Entourage, Season 2


Entourage is TV fluff, but it's very enjoyable fluff, about a reguar young actor from New York who manages to get spotted and become the next-big-thing in Hollywood. Season 2 follows the continuing adventures of him and his three best mates as they enjoy the LA-life of pampering, parties and gorgeous women, while keeping his career on track in the fickle world of showbusiness. Funny dialogue, A-list cameos, and vicarious thrills keep me coming back for more. (7/10)