Showing posts with label ancient world. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ancient world. Show all posts

Monday, September 22, 2008

Books: Mesopotamia: The invention of the city


Mesopotamia: The invention of the city (Gwendolyn Leick) tells the story of the ancient near east through the lens of ten key Mesopotamian cities. Beginning in Eridu, one of the first cities in the Near East, or indeed anywhere in the world, and progressing through Uruk, Ur and on to Ashur, Nineveh and Babylon, the entire history of the period is able to be explored.

Unfortunately, for me, the emphasis is rather too much on the archaeology and architecture, and too little on the characters and lifestyles of the time. A useful refresher, with some interesting new ideas (the hanging gardens of Babylon were most likely hundreds of miles away in Nineveh, and had certainly never been seen by the Greeks who listed the Seven Wonders), but ultimately much too dry for the casual reader. (3/10)

Friday, May 30, 2008

Books: The kingdom of the Hittites


The kingdom of the Hittites (Trevor Bryce) is a comprehensive, not too dry account of the birth of the Hittite people of ancient Anatolia, their various kings, political and military adventures, and eventual destruction. Although not overburdened with the academic references or wranglings over veracity that can make reading ancient history a chore, the book certainly doesn't have the dramatic feel of, say, Joyce Tyldesley's work. It's also a bit too long, considering that there is no discussion whatsoever of society, arts, religion, architecture, or any of the things that can really bring these accounts to life.

Most interesting are the sections of the book on beginnings and endings, how does a people come to prominence and what eventually brings it down? I find any discussion of the 'Sea People' fascinating, those mysterious forces who seem to have brought the entire Bronze Age Near East to its knees, and there's also a lovely final chapter that tries to unpick the truth behind the Trojan War. Seeing the interrelations between the Hittites and other Near Eastern states is also enjoyable, with the Egyptian showdown at Kadesh proving a centre-piece. All in all, The kingdom of the Hittites remains a decent, though fairly unexciting, account of the period. (5/10)

Monday, January 28, 2008

Books: Mesopotamia: writing, reasoning and the gods


Mesopotamia: writing, reasoning and the gods (Jean Bottero) avoids discussion of the political or social history of the region entirely, and concentrates its focus on the way the people of Sumer and Akkad thought. By analysing the development of language and exploring a number of surviving literary works Bottero attempts to convey just how alien this ancient civilization was to our own. But even while stressing the impossibility of transposing our own values and viewpoints to the ancient past, the book also examines the ways in which this cradle of Western civilization has influenced our present. The book is fascinating, and the author's enthusiasm comes across on every page, unashamedly advocating academic inquiry and the acquisition of useless knowledge for its own sake. (7/10)

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Books: Egyptian myth: a very short introduction


Egyptian myth: a very short introduction (Geraldine Harris) makes what should be an interesting subject rather dry. The book introduces the major gods and their relationships, looks at the stories of creation and the recurring themes within the mythology, and explores the Egyptians' belief in a fundamental struggle between order and chaos. Useful lists of gods, motifs, festivals and so on, are clearly presented, making this a good reference text, but everything is explained with such an academic detachment as to drain the enjoyment out of Egypt's colourful mythology. (4/10)

Thursday, October 04, 2007

Books: Egypt's golden empire


In an earlier review I mentioned my dislike of books on Ancient Egypt that boil down to "lists of unpronouncable and impossible-to-remember pharaohs." In Egypt's golden empire Joyce Tyldesley does what I'd though impossible, given the sparsity of reliable sources, and brings those pharaohs to life. Focusing on the New Kingdom period, the book describes the reigns of each of the kings, graphically depicting the battles they fought, the court intrigues they faced, the majestic buildings they commissioned and the circumstances of their deaths.

The readable, almost novelistic style of Egypt's golden empire no doubt glosses over large areas of dispute among historians and uncertainty about the time, and I'm sure it would be a very irritating read for any serious scholar of the subject, but this makes it perfect reading for the rest of us. Beginning with the brutal death of Kamose, who ushered in the New Kingdom, we meet the great warriors Ahmose, Thutmosis III and Rameses II, the builder Amenhotep III and the female king Hatshepsut, the heretic Akhenaten who turned Eyptian tradition on its head, and the most famous of all pharaohs, Tutankhamun the boy king. (8/10)

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Books: Egypt and the Egyptians


Egypt and the Egyptians (Douglas Brewer & Emily Teeter) is a quick read but manages to pack in pretty much everything an amateur history buff might want to know about the ancient civilization. The book begins with a chapter on the geography of the Nile and its delta, and the way the landscape shaped the people. The historical progression from Old to Middle to New Kingdoms, the Late Period and the Intermediate Periods in between, which would be the sum total of many books on the subject, is covered in one chapter here; a sensible move that keeps the lists of unpronouncable and impossible-to-remember pharaohs to a minimum.

In place of the historical narrative, Egypt and the Egyptians devotes its remaining chapters to aspects of Ancient Egyptian society, for example: modes of government, social roles and entertainment, the arts, religion, and a particularly interesting section on the relationship between the hieroglyphic, hieratic, demotic and coptic languages. The pyramids are discussed, of course, but in the wider context of the Egyptians' obsession with, and preparation for, the afterlife. The text is illustrated throughout with photographs, maps and diagrams of temples, tombs, flood-plains, cities, and much more. Easy to understand, but never coming across as simplistic, this is a great introduction to the land and its people. (7/10)

Friday, August 24, 2007

Books: The Oxford history of ancient Egypt


As an enthusiast, reading about ancient Egypt for pleasure rather than academic study, The Oxford history of ancient Egypt (ed. Ian Shaw) was just a little too dry for me. In fact I gave up on it before the half-way mark. There are almost no maps in the book to orient the reader, and few illustrations to help understand the ceramic styles or tomb layouts that are being described. Focussing very heavily on the progression of kings and dynasties there is little on the development of language, religion, or other cultural aspects of the Egyptian civilization.

Each chapter is written by a different author, and some are certainly more engaging than others. As a book for students of the subject I suspect it would be very good. (4/10)

Sunday, July 22, 2007

TV: Rome, Season 2


Having read quite a bit about ancient Rome, I could never quite get over the historical inaccuracies of Rome the series. It wasn't the plots that bothered me; it's easy to forgive the writers taking short-cuts and condensing complex events into more easily digestible storylines. What I couldn't accept was the way that the character traits of these historical figures were distorted out of all recognition, diminishing Julius Caesar in the first season and Caesar Octavian in the second and portraying Antony and Brutus as heroic, likeable characters when they were anything but. The scheming Servilia was transformed into a saint and Atia, practically a nonentity in historical terms, took the antagonist role that should have been Servilia's. Cleopatra, the noble, intelligent queen was perhaps worst served of all.

Even aside from these irritations, the plotting, dialogue, acting, etc. were never particularly engaging. The show was wonderful to look at, a vivid and convincing depiction of the ancient world, but it never became 'must-see' tv for me. (7/10)

Saturday, June 09, 2007

Books: The epic of Gilgamesh


After God decides to destroy mankind by flooding the Earth, one man builds an arc, loads it up with all the livestock he can find and sets sail. Eventually he runs aground on a mountaintop and sends out a dove to find land. His name is not Noah but Uta-napishti, and his tale is told not in the Bible but in The epic of Gilgamesh, written about 2000 years before Jesus of Nazareth was born.

The story starts in Uruk (the first city) and tells the story of it's king Gilgamesh and his friend, the wild-man Enkidu. These two tough guys start by beating each other up, then go off together to beat up an ogre in the Forest of Ceders, and finally beat up the bull Taurus, brought down from the night sky by a vengeful goddess. In between the fighting the two guys spend a lot of time holding hands and crying... so the story feels part Rambo, part Brokeback Mountain.

It's all good fun, and Gilgamesh makes for an intersting character, beginning as an arrogant tyrant and maturing as he comes to accept his own mortality. Unfortunately though, being that the sources are so old, much of the text is missing and the translation is peppered with elipses and lacunae. It's very hard to get into the rhythm of the language when sentences keep breaking off and the story skips like a scratched record. It's worth persevering though, if only to know that you've read the oldest story in human history. (6/10)

Friday, May 11, 2007

Books: A history of the ancient Near East: ca. 3000-323 BC


A history of the ancient Near East: ca. 3000-323 BC (Marc van de Mieroop) is my second attempt to read a book on this period. I originally tried Amelie Khurt's two-volume The ancient Near East C3000-330 BC, but found it far too dense and overly academic. van de Mieroop's book is much more readable, with plenty of maps and time-lines to help keep the reader oriented. It doesn't get too caught up in all the uncertainties about the period, or how we know what we know, but clearly follows the various cultures of the near east as they wax and wane.

The book begins with the emergence of Uruk as the first ever city and looks at the ways in which urban life accelerated the progression of technology and culture and led to the development of writing and political life. Gradually city states come into being and begin to compete, they develop into the great territories of the Hittites, Babylonians, Assyrians, and Egyptians, which ultimately leads to the creation of empires that span the known world.

Every aspect of the civilisations are covered as far as possible, from home life to social uprisings to language and the arts, from the great leaders to the rarely-understood societal collapses. The only problem - and this is a difficulty with the period rather than the book itself - is that the patchy nature of the sources makes it hard to really understand everything that happened, and particularly to empathise with or understand the key figures of the period. When reading about the republic of Rome, for example, characters like Caesar and Sulla can come to life in a way that Sargon of Akkad never will.

Nevertheless, this is a fascinating book that's perfect for the lay-person with an interest in ancient history. (7/10)