Saturday, October 25, 2008

Films: Burn after reading


It's hard to mistake a Coen Brother's film. Their dialogue is so distinctive and there's that pervasive sense of absurdity and futility enveloping everything they produce. Yet each of their movies is also completely unlike the others, with the Coen's apparently determined to pay homage to every genre of film in turn. They've done the police procedural, the American gangster, romantic comedy, 1950s noir, and the deep south, and now, with Burn after reading, they turn their attention to the spy thriller.

John Malkovich, George Clooney, Frances McDormand, Brad Pitt and Tilda Swinton star, and all help to create characters as memorable, idiosyncratic and bizarre as in any Coen film before them. The plot involves a web of lies, deceipt, and misunderstandings that quickly spins away into nonsense, and that's pretty much the point. Things happen, they don't always make much sense or tie up neatly in the end, but they are funny and unpredictable, and rather a lot like life. (7/10)

Thursday, October 16, 2008

TV: The wire, Season 4


When I wrote about Season 1 of The wire, I compared it unfavorably to The Sopranos, saying that it failed to so perfectly reflect the concerns and aspirations of the modern middle-class family-man. Of course, that was never the point. The wire is about the forgotten people, the people who never make it to American TV, the poor, worn-down blue-collar workers and criminals, trying to make it on the outskirts of society. The wire is not about understanding yourself, it's about trying to understand the others.

As in Season 2, this season relaxes the focus on the drug war, instead turning attention to the Baltimore school system. Another system that is failing and corrupted and corrupting, like the political world and the police force and the dockworkers' union and the drug gangs that have gone before it.

Four young boys make their way through a school year, trying to work out what they can expect from a future with depressingly limited options. They are played by a stunning set of child actors who sell perfectly the false bravado, the bubbling potential and the deep scars that are part and parcel of growing up on the streets. Meanwhile, all the old characters return, some with very new outlooks on life, and the great, multi-faceted, totally absorbing TV-novel that is The wire continues. (10/10)

Monday, October 13, 2008

Films: 8 women


My friends who like this film try to tell me that it's great fun and very silly and that it should be enjoyed on that level, but for me it's just a mess. I like silly, I like Doctor Who and Buffy the Vampire Slayer and The Big Lebowski, but being silly and being intelligent don't have to be mutually exclusive.

8 women (d. François Ozon) is a highly stylised spoof of the whodunnit, with eight women isolated in a big house in a snow storm discovering a dead body and wondering which of them is the murderer. The set design and costume design are wonderful, and dramatic, with each of the characters practically jumping off the screen like walking, talking cartoons. The plotting is also funny, with preposterous secrets piling on top of ridiculous twists.

The problem comes with the acting and directing, which is shocking. The tone veers wildly from comedy to pathos, with the most embarrasingly broad mugging followed immediately by tears and life-lessons and tender moments. What's more, it's a musical. Every now and then the characters burst into song, singing songs that are neither funny, nor clever, nor appropriate to the scene in question. I didn't laugh, I didn't care, and I can't imagine what anyone sees in this film. (2/10)

Saturday, October 04, 2008

Books: Trauma


Trauma (Patrick McGrath) is the story of a New York psychoanalyst, a specialist in post-traumatic stress disorder, whose past mistakes and own traumas come back to haunt him. The characters are very precisely drawn; his antagonistic brother, his emotionally intelligent ex-wife, his disturbed girlfriend, and so on; but none of them are particularly interesting or entertaining.

The novel is written in a rather inoffensive style that manages to elicit some vague interest in the outcome, but I'm not really sure what it is for. It isn't particularly suspenseful or dramatic, there are certainly no insights into individual behaviour or modern society, and there's no humour whatsoever. It feels like an attempt to be both psychological thriller and literary, character-driven fiction, but one that fails to be satisfying on either count. (5/10)

Thursday, October 02, 2008

Films: Grizzly man


Grizzly man (d. Werner Herzog) is a documentary film about Timothy Treadwell, an animal-rights activist who went out to live with the grizzly bears of Alaska every summer for over a decade. Treadwell filmed himself interacting with the bears, and Herzog uses the film to explore the life and psyche of this man who loved these bears with all his heart, and came to feel closer to the animals than he did to any human.

It's a thought-provoking exploration of those people who see such romance in nature that they become blinded to its brutality, and the conclusion is appropriately macabre. After 13 summers living amongst them, Treadwell is killed and eaten by one of the bears to whom he had devoted his life. (8/10)