Thursday, January 29, 2009

Books: Wild swans


Wild swans (Jung Chang) is a baggy, often interminable biography and autobiography of a Chinese woman, her mother and grandmother, which spans about a century of history, and seems to take just as long to read. Chang seems unable to stop herself from detailing every notable incident of her life, and the lives of her parents and grandparents. Before long, this barrage of story snippets and banal details ceases to have any emotional impact whatsoever. I think it's telling that, in talking about Wild swans, most people bring up the barbarous foot binding custom that is the first thing described and thus one of the only parts that stands out.

There is no craft to the writing whatsoever; everything from beautiful countryside to vicious torture is described in the same monotonous prose. And none of the supporting characters (of whom there are a multitude) are given enough time to develop into people you might care about.

Yet, despite all this, it's a book worth reading. Why? Because it tells a story that needs to be heard; the story of the rise of Communism in China, of the euphoria that greeted this new direction for the country, in which the poor and disenfranchised would be looked after, and corruption and exploitation would be banished. Followed, of course, by a gradual descent into nightmare and carnage that rivals the most disturbing horror film. I'll admit that, other than the name Mao Tse-tung, I didn't have the faintest idea of what the country went through in the mid-20th Century. It's utterly astonishing, and horrendous, and like the Holocaust or the Greek-Turkish wars, a real slap in the face to realise that humans have done these things to each other so recently, and that awareness of them is often so lacking.

Could Wild swans have lost two thirds of it's length, and been a better book for it? Yes.
Am I sorry that I struggled through it? Definitely not. (5/10)

No comments: