
Dave Eggers' What is the what is an important, commendable book, but reading it is not a pleasurable experience. Partly this is because of the subject matter, which is quite miserable, but also because of the fact that it simply isn't very well written.
The novel tells the true story of Valentino Achak Deng who was born in a small village in southern Sudan and lived there until the age of seven when he was forced to flee by the government-funded militia during a flare-up of the civil war. One of thousands of displaced migrants, Valentino walked to Ethiopia and then to Kenya, enduring many hardships and living much of his life in refugee camps. Eventually he was resettled in the US, and it is from this vantage point that his tale is told.
Unfortunately, what should have been a powerful book is let down by a complete absence of narrative style. The storytelling lacks the grittiness and vibrancy of something like City of God, and the moments of horror and humour, sadness and delight, which could have been heart-wrenching, fail to make an impact. That's not to deny that I felt a lump in my throat as the story reached its climax; it would be hard to read What is the what without being somewhat affected, and certainly I'm better informed about the situation in Sudan than I was. There are moments of interest: the cultural adjustments the Sudanese have to make as they are introduced into the developed world, and the friendship Valentino develops with a Japanese aid-worker stand out; but the overriding emotional responses as you plod through this book are frustration and boredom. (5/10)

















































































































No comments:
Post a Comment