Thursday, July 17, 2008

Films: Dark city


From the opening frames it's clear that Dark city (d. Alex Proyas) is something extraordinary, an agglomeration of so many different influences and styles that it becomes fully its own animal. By far the closest comparison is The Matrix, with which it shares a similarly stylised look, a plot in which science fiction bleeds into real life, and a focus on the true nature of reality and humanity. It's not as polished as the Matrix, of course; the effects are a bit more wobbly and Kiefer Sutherland's mad scientist is even hammier than Morpheus.

But this is more than just a precursor to The Matrix. So many other influences are at play. Imagine sticking that film into a blender with Tim Burton, Hammer Horror, Strange days, 1950s noir, and you start to get a sense of what this film, about an amnesiac waking in a city of perpetual night, is like. Sutherland is joined by the frankly bizarre Richard O'Brien, plus William Hurt, and to my utter delight, one of my all-time biggest crushes, Jennifer Connelly. Singing mambo, no less.

Dark city is not a perfect film, not quite, but what a fascinating, freakish creation it is. (9/10)

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Films: Mamma mia!


While not diabolically bad, Mamma mia! (d. Phyllida Lloyd) is certainly a pretty poor excuse for a movie. The best thing about it is Meryl Streep, as the mother of a bride who decides to invite her three potential fathers to the wedding. It's done as a musical, set entirely to ABBA, and Streep really can sing, putting a lot of heart into many of the numbers.

Unfortunately, most of the rest of the cast are tone-deaf, or simply boring. Worse, the attempt to shoe-horn ABBA lyrics into the wedding plot, makes a nonsense of both. These connections are not only tenuous, but occasionally disturbing, with one song, about romantic love, being sung by a daughter to her imaginary dad. Icky. The characters are paper thin, their histories unexplained, their decisions illogical, but none of this would matter if only the music carried you away and got your toes tapping. It doesn't, which makes this an unimpressive film in every respect. (4/10)

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Films: Jules et Jim


Jules et Jim (d. Francoise Truffaut) is a French film from the Sixties about two friends divided by a desirable, manipulative woman. There's a freshness and naturalism here that feels very contemporary; an attention to the mundane yet fascinating details of people's worlds, which makes the characters come alive. It's a technique that reminded me of Amelie, a film that owes much to Jules et Jim, including the use of an omniscient, dead-pan narrator.

As with Breakfast at Tiffany's, I found it hard to empathise with the disollute leading lady but here there are two thoroughly likeable, troubled suitors, and it's easy to care about their friendship and its destruction. (7/10)

Films: Kung fu panda


For the first time, Dreamworks has produced a 3D animation that matches up to the best of Pixar. The reason is that, unlike Shrek and it's ilk, Kung fu panda (d. John Stevenson) doesn't pander. There's no attempt to appeal to adults by shoe-horning in pop-culture references, or to little kids by relying on fart jokes; instead we get a simple, beautifully crafted, action-packed kung fu fable. The choreography and oriental-inspired design are eye-wateringly lovely, and the characters are funny, without ever being crass or knowing. (8/10)

Monday, July 07, 2008

Books: The missing persons' guide to love


The missing persons' guide to love (Susanna Jones) is about a woman who returns to the village she grew up in to investigate the years-old disappearance of her best friend from school.

The book is a strange combination. It has a plot that's compelling enough to keep you turning the pages, looking for answers to the central mystery; are we reading about a murder, an abduction, or a teenage runaway? Unfortunately, this is combined with a writing style that's bland at best, and insulting at worst. None of the characters feel like real people, neither speaking nor acting in a way that's remotely recognizable to me. It's the sort of book that seems to be obscured behind a fog of ambiguity, attempting to enchance the tension by having the central character become increasinly unhinged, bewildered and bewildering.

Many of the lapses in the writing could, perhaps, have been forgiven though, if it weren't for the horrible, cop-out ending. The resolution manages to undermine everything that has gone before it, making me feel cheated, and leaving me scratching my head as to what the book is actually about, if anything. (4/10)

Sunday, July 06, 2008

TV: Doctor Who, Season 4


Baring a few one-off specials in 2009, Russel T. Davies' run on Doctor Who comes to an end with Season 4. It's been a great four years, and although Davies himself has been hit-and-miss, his high-points have been outstanding. His greatest achievement was to bring the show back after so long, with special effects and production values and acting talent that easily eclipsed the programme that I grew up with, yet retaining the essence of Doctor Who. The clunkiness, the kitch, the family-friendly horror... for some it's all just a bit too silly, but most people, happily, seem able to embrace the new version as an utterly charming slice of British telly. Just at it always was.

This latest season re-introduced Catherine Tate as Donna Noble, a temping secretary plodding through her life, who, having met the Doctor, can't rest until she finds him again and joins him on his adventures through space and time. To be honest, the quality of the episodes this year hasn't seemed quite as high as the last, and perhaps that is down to Tate. Things get very dark for Donna towards the end, and her resulting distress is played extremely well, but for much of the rest of the season Tate simply falls back on her comedy persona, never quite seeming to fit in with the tone of the show.

The highlights, as with the preceding three years, were the episodes by Stephen Moffat. He knows how to write 'scary', it's true, but he's also easily as witty as anything the new series has to offer, and by far the most complex in his plotting. A real joy to watch, and meaty enough to be worth a second viewing.

The season concludes with a universe-shaking conflict with the evil daleks, bringing all of the Doctor's recent companions together in one climactic showdown. Although, of course, the good guys win and there's even an unexpected romantic twist, the ending is surprisingly downbeat. One character suffers a horrible fate, arguably a fate worse than death, and the Doctor ends as he began: totally alone. A satisfying conclusion were it not for the glaringly obvious absence of Christopher Eccleston, who was clearly intended to appear as the Doctor's previous incarnation. One final fly in the ointment of a season that was fun but never quite as good as it might have been. (8/10)

Friday, July 04, 2008

Comics: Y: The last man, Vol. 10: Whys and wherefores


I knew I wanted to keep living in any world that you were a part of.
But that was hard to admit to myself... and not just because it ended with a preposition.

How many times has a fantastic story, in any medium, been let down by a mediocre ending? Too many times for me to count. Much as I wanted to love the last episodes of The Sopranos, Buffy, The West Wing, or Doctor Who, they all finished up just a little below the high standard we'd come to expect. Y: the last man, which concludes with Volume 10, Whys and wherefores, ends perfectly.

The story of Yorick, the only male human to survive a global plague that spared all those without a Y chromosome, has dipped in quality from time to time; some volumes are less essential than others; but this last book succeeds in every regard. The snarky banter and wordplay are here, the knowing nods to the audience remain, and the action continues apace. But what I never expected was how hard this story would hit me on an emotional level. There's a terrible scene towards the end of the book that I never saw coming, and quite honestly, when it happened, I found that I just didn't want to turn the page and have it be real. I sat there with the book on my lap and found it really quite hard to keep reading. And to get that sort of reaction from a comic strip? Amazing.

Y: the last man, the whole story, is a rollicking read. As spelt out in the concluding volume, it's a classic boys' own adventure, with pirates and astronauts, robots and ninjas, but with barely a boy in sight. It's been smart, thought-provoking, and surprisingly moving, and while I'm sad it's over, I couldn't have wished for a better ending. (10/10)

Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Books: Tales from Ancient Egypt


Tales from Ancient Egypt (Joyce Tyldesley) is a collection of stories, some about gods, some about men, some true, some fiction, from Ancient Egypt. They have been adapted by the author for the modern reader, removing the repetition and glossing over the inevitable gaps in the narrative, where possible. Unfortunately this still leaves a number of tales that are missing the beginning, or more distressingly the end. One of the most enjoyable tales in here, about a doomed prince who knows he will die by dog, snake or crocodile and does everything possible to avoid his fate, is an uncomplicated, involving story that frustratingly gets cut off just prior to the climax.

The creation myths and stories of warring gods are the highlight of the book, although even these come across as muddled and a little unsatisfying. Certainly there is nothing in here to rival The Epic of Gilgamesh and so it's unsuprising that they haven't survived in popular consciousness nearly as well. Perhaps the greatest value is not in the stories as stories, but firstly as a window into the concerns and lifestyles of these ancient peoples, and secondly as an illustration of how many fairytales and biblical parables have their roots thousands of years earlier than one might expect. (5/10)

Saturday, June 28, 2008

Films: The swimmer


The swimmer (d. Frank Perry) is one classic film that does hold up well over time. It's difficult to say too much without spoiling it, but suffice to say that it stars Burt Lancaster as an aging life-of-the-party lothario who's out for a walk in beautiful New York State one day and decides to swim home via the swimming pools of all the houses in the neighbourhood. The journey is not just physical, but psychological, as the swimmer's past is gradually, eliptically revealed, resulting in a wonderfully portrayed, and rather melodramatic meltdown. (8/10)

Friday, June 20, 2008

Food: Graze

One of the best dining experiences in Brighton can be had at Graze on Western Road. A plush, intimate setting and friendly staff set you up for an evening of delicious seasonal food. The idea is that rather than have two or three normally sized courses (and thus miss out on the full range of tempting goodies on offer), you get seven, or even nine, small but perfectly formed dishes and get to graze to your heart's content.

Ham ravioli in fresh pea soup, rabbit confit and breast, and succulent crab meat served on gazpatcho stood out particularly, with dozens of suprising flavours complementing each other beautifully. And finishing up with two puddings seems like the perfect way to end a meal! My only reservation is that the portions were so small; seven courses later and I was hungry for more. (9/10)

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Books: The portrait of Mrs Charbuque


The portrait of Mrs Charbuque (Jeffrey Ford) is a novel that's extremely difficult to categorise. Set in New York in the late 19th Century it follows a painter, Piambo, who is disillusioned with his work, involving as it does the production of an endless stream of falsely flattering portraits for the rich and vain. Then, approached by a blind butler, Piambo is commissioned to paint the mysterious Mrs Charbuque, with the promise of a princely remuneration on the proviso that Piambo never be allowed to lay eyes on his model, only to converse with her, hidden behind an opaque screen. His curiosity piqued, the painter jumps at the chance.

What follows is a story that weaves together the eponymous lady's fantastical childhood, the psychological disintigration of our heroic painter, and a murder mystery founded on an ancient poison. The whole thing sounds wonderfully arcane and gothic when summarised in this way, full of the potential for Gaiman-esque goodness, but keeping a grip on these implausible threads requires a skilled, engaging author, and Ford, sadly, is not up to the task.

The writing is thin and hystrionic, and a reasonably strong start deteriorates as the book wears on, to end up reading like a bad thriller rolled up with the worst sort of boddice-ripping romance. A number of intriguing and inventive ideas are let down by a writing style that fails to elicit more than a shrug of mild disinterest. (5/10).

Sunday, June 08, 2008

TV: Battlestar Galactica, Season 3


The new Battlestar Galactica just gets more and more interesting with each passing season. It's a science fiction epic, yes, but with the sort of grimy, hard-bitten, cinematic edge that brings it far closer to Band of brothers or Saving Private Ryan than any television sf that's gone before. It's also a political and religious allegory, with suicide bombings and religious zealots, and the audience on the 'wrong' side.

But most of all it's a story of a brave but jaded group of refugees fleeing for their lives across the stars, a story that grips you hard and barely lets up for a moment. Beginning with a fight for freedom and ending with death, and a revelation of the enemies within, Season 3 ups the ante once more. (9/10)

Friday, June 06, 2008

Films: Ping pong


Ping pong (d. Fumihiko Sori) is a Japanese film that takes the sports movie genre and applies it to table-tennis. Two school friends, both gifted with a bat, become allies and then rivals in a bid to grab the highest accolade in the world of high-school ping-pong.

Funny and surreal at times, the story has its roots in manga and the skewed, stylish aesthetic of the best of modern Eastern cinema. If there's a complaint it's that the film goes on too long, and that despite the inventive camera-work, many of the hyperactive faceoffs over-stay their welcome. (7/10)

Sunday, June 01, 2008

Films: Dead Poets' Society


I wonder if Dead Poets' Society (d. Peter Weir) is a film that struck a particular chord at the time it was released, or perhaps it taps into a feeling of naive teenage rebellion, which fades over time, but leaves a nostalgic glow in anyone who sees the film early on in life... Whatever the reason for the film's high standing, viewing it for the first time now is a disappointing experience.

It's bad enough to have to swallow the idea that a group of cynical, exuberant, sexual young men would consider reading poetry in a cave to be the height of excitement and daring, but that this love of literature would lead a boy to the extreme actions at the culmination of the film is utterly preposterous. When the grand climax involves nothing more exciting than a class of kids standing on their desks it becomes clear that some fine acting from Robin Williams, and the rest of the young cast, can't save this watery, bland, unconvincing movie. (5/10)

Friday, May 30, 2008

Books: The kingdom of the Hittites


The kingdom of the Hittites (Trevor Bryce) is a comprehensive, not too dry account of the birth of the Hittite people of ancient Anatolia, their various kings, political and military adventures, and eventual destruction. Although not overburdened with the academic references or wranglings over veracity that can make reading ancient history a chore, the book certainly doesn't have the dramatic feel of, say, Joyce Tyldesley's work. It's also a bit too long, considering that there is no discussion whatsoever of society, arts, religion, architecture, or any of the things that can really bring these accounts to life.

Most interesting are the sections of the book on beginnings and endings, how does a people come to prominence and what eventually brings it down? I find any discussion of the 'Sea People' fascinating, those mysterious forces who seem to have brought the entire Bronze Age Near East to its knees, and there's also a lovely final chapter that tries to unpick the truth behind the Trojan War. Seeing the interrelations between the Hittites and other Near Eastern states is also enjoyable, with the Egyptian showdown at Kadesh proving a centre-piece. All in all, The kingdom of the Hittites remains a decent, though fairly unexciting, account of the period. (5/10)

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

Books: Moon tiger


There is a particular breed of film that people with a certain sensibility flock to see. These films will have long shots of beautiful scenery, purple mountains shrouded in mist, glassy lakes, falling leaves, and as little plot as possible so as not to distract from the lucious photography. Moon tiger by Penelope Lively is the literary equivalent. The prose is assured, and at times poetic, the dialogue is sharp and seemingly portentous, but evidently a story, a theme, or a nuanced characterisation would just get in the way.

The book follows a woman called Claudia through her life, a life bisected by the Second World War, during which she is a reporter on the Egyptian front. Claudia is witty, biting, misanthropic, and relatively unsympathetic, and her co-stars are either just like her, or are utterly dull, soft and unimaginative. The only character to escape these extremes is Tom the soldier, the love of her life, who is a perfect specimen of self-assured, self-depricating manliness. Unfortunately, none of these underwritten characters grow or change over the course of the story, and neither is there any tension, nor unexpected twists within the plot. Moon tiger won the Booker Prize in 1987, and I can only assume that the judges were so won over by the writing that they failed to notice that nothing actually happens. (5/10)

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Films: Iron Man


From the moment Robert Downey Jr was cast as Tony Stark in Iron Man it was clear that director Jon Favreau was on the right track. It's hard to imagine someone more perfect to play the cocky, charming, alcoholic, billionaire inventor than Downey, and indeed he more than lives up to expectations. Up there with Batman begins as one of the most faithful, stylish and fun comic-book adaptations yet made, Iron Man has action, humour and romance to spare. Not to mention some beautifully designed special effects that should appeal to the big kid in everyone. I'm looking forward to the sequel already. (9/10)

Thursday, May 08, 2008

TV: Life on Mars, Season 1


I've written previously about how impressed I've been by Life on Mars, which had such a strange premise that I put off watching it for years. Sam Tyler, a police officer from the present, gets knocked unconscious and wakes up in 1972, where he joins the Manchester force and solves crimes alongside the unreconstructed Neanderthal DCI Gene Hunt. Is it science-fiction? A detective show? Both, or neither?

In the end it doesn't matter because so many of the episodes in Season 1 are so wonderfully well-written, witty, surreal and incredibly pacy. Not every episode is unforgettable, but they're all good fun, with Sam trying desperately to work out what's going on, while the supporting cast send up the unenlightened Seventies perfectly. (7/10)

Monday, May 05, 2008

Films: Hustle & Flow


Telling the story of a pimp who dreams of becoming a hip-hop artist could be done wrong in about half-a-dozen different ways. Hustle & flow (d. Craig Brewer) does it right. The lives of DJay and his girls, working the streets of Memphis, are soul-destroying and bleak, but Brewer makes them incredibly sympathetic without glamorising or sanitising their world. To drag themselves out of this gutter-scraping lifestyle is very close to impossible, and seeing them try to do it is incredibly touching. (8/10)

Thursday, May 01, 2008

Books: LibraryThing's Top 106 Unread Books

These are the books must often tagged 'unread' on LibraryThing. You're supposed to mark the ones you haven't read but want to - the problem is I want to read them all.


The way it works: Bold books you've read, italicize books started but unfinished and strikethrough books you've hated:

  1. Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell

  2. Anna Karenina

  3. Crime and Punishment

  4. Catch-22

  5. One Hundred Years of Solitude

  6. Wuthering Heights

  7. The Silmarillion

  8. Life of Pi: a novel

  9. The Name of the Rose

  10. Don Quixote

  11. Moby Dick

  12. Ulysses

  13. Madame Bovary

  14. The Odyssey

  15. Pride and Prejudice

  16. Jane Eyre

  17. A Tale of Two Cities

  18. The Brothers Karamazov

  19. Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies

  20. War and Peace

  21. Vanity Fair

  22. The Time Traveller’s Wife

  23. The Iliad

  24. Emma

  25. The Blind Assassin

  26. The Kite Runner

  27. Mrs. Dalloway

  28. Great Expectations

  29. American Gods

  30. A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius

  31. Atlas Shrugged

  32. Reading Lolita in Tehran

  33. Memoirs of a Geisha

  34. Middlesex

  35. Quicksilver

  1. Wicked : The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West

  2. The Canterbury Tales (an illustrated children's version admittedly!)

  3. The Historian

  4. A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

  5. Love in the Time of Cholera

  6. Brave New World

  7. The Fountainhead

  8. Foucault’s Pendulum

  9. Middlemarch

  10. Frankenstein

  11. The Count of Monte Cristo

  12. Dracula

  13. A Clockwork Orange

  14. Anansi Boys

  15. The Once and Future King

  16. The Grapes of Wrath

  17. The Poisonwood Bible

  18. 1984

  19. Angels & Demons

  20. The Inferno

  21. The Satanic Verses

  22. Sense and Sensibility

  23. The Picture of Dorian Gray

  24. Mansfield Park

  25. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest

  26. To the Lighthouse

  27. Tess of the D’Urbervilles

  28. Oliver Twist

  29. Gulliver’s Travels

  30. Les Misérables

  31. The Corrections

  32. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay

  33. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

  34. Dune

  35. The Prince

  1. The Sound and the Fury

  2. Angela’s Ashes

  3. The God of Small Things

  4. A People’s History of the United States : 1492-Present

  5. Cryptonomicon

  6. Neverwhere

  7. A Confederacy of Dunces

  8. A Short History of Nearly Everything

  9. Dubliners

  10. The Unbearable Lightness of Being

  11. Beloved

  12. Slaughterhouse-Five

  13. The Scarlet Letter

  14. Eats, Shoots & Leaves

  15. The Mists of Avalon

  16. Oryx and Crake

  17. Collapse : how societies choose to fail or succeed

  18. Cloud Atlas

  19. The Confusion

  20. Lolita

  21. Persuasion

  22. Northanger Abbey

  23. The Catcher in the Rye

  24. On the Road

  25. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

  26. Freakonomics

  27. Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance

  28. The Aeneid

  29. Watership Down

  30. Gravity’s Rainbow

  31. The Hobbit

  32. In Cold Blood

  33. White Teeth

  34. Treasure Island

  35. David Copperfield

  36. The Three Musketeers

Monday, April 21, 2008

TV: Arrested development, Season 3


Arrested development was a doomed experiment to make an American comedy about unlikeable people, in which you get the joke three seconds after the punchline instead of thirty seconds before. Likened to a live-action Simpsons, the series follows Michael Blooth, the good-hearted son in a family of crooked property developers, as he and they get themselves into increasingly unlikely situations.

A clever script, full of in-jokes and verbal dexterity, delivered by an astonishing cast that could make the obituaries sound funny, make me very sad that this truncated Season 3 is the last we'll see of the Blooths. (9/10)

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Films: Tape


Reminiscent of Before sunrise and Before sunset, Richard Linklater's Tape bravely limits itself to three characters talking in a single motel room. It says a lot for the director that such a pared-down film can hold one's attention for ninety minutes, and it does, although unfortunately the story, which remains so compelling for so long, totally fizzles out at the end. Not to mention that Sunrise and Sunset placed their long conversations against the backdrop of two of the most beautiful cities in the world, making the most of their visual medium, as opposed to this, which could just as easily have been a radio-play. (5/10)

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Films: Son of Rambow


Son of Rambow (d. Garth Jennings) is a British film about two school kids, one a disruptive trouble-maker, the other a good-as-gold Plymouth Brethren boy, who decide to recreate Rambo on home video. Watching them attempting to immitate the stunts in various completely irresponsible ways is entertaining, and the two leads ensure that the story of burgeoning friendship remains engaging. But unfortunately there's too much else going on, with French exchange students, religious nutcases, and threatening older brothers; leaving the film very unfocussed. There are lots of good ideas but none of them has enough screen time to really take off. (6/10)

Monday, April 14, 2008

TV: The wire, Season 2


Season 2 of The wire takes the already complex and sprawling storyline from the first season, and ups the ante. Beginning with characters from every level of two well-developed organisations; the Baltimore police department and the drugs gang it's fighting; the new season brings in a third cohort, members of the Polish dock-workers guild, who interrelate with the existing cast in multiple ways. The web of characters becomes so vast that concentration is required to keep a handle on the plot, but manage to ride along with it and you begin to feel as though you know the city of Baltimore inside and out.

As before, there is a target to bring down, a surveillance operation to set up, and a case to build, slowly and carefully. There are beaurcratic hurdles, numerous set-backs, occasional small victories, and a dramatic, emotional, but very real conclusion. This is a dark and grimy world that's being explored, full of drug addicts covered in sores and police whose personal lives are in tatters, but the show manages to find much more humour than in Season 1, which is a blessing and does a lot to elevate the programme into something truly great. (9/10)

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Books: Hangover Square


Hangover Square (Patrick Hamilton) is a simple story about a group of dissolute characters hanging around in London in the 1930s, getting drunk, getting up late, and doing not much else besides. The central figure, the lumbering and sympathetic George Harvey Bone, has fallen for Netta Longdon, a beautiful woman around whom everyone revolves. Netta is beautiful and yet completely, utterly horrid; vindictive, avaricious, and callous, she leads Bone on when she wants something and treats him with utter disdain when she's got it.

The book is a painfully acute examination of this destructive relationship, of this ordinary, sad man who knows just what Netta is but can't break free of his addiction to her. Reading about George is hard because no matter how many times he gets screwed over by this woman, he always believes that this time is different, this time she really wants him, and every time he gets his heart ripped out once more. And he's such a nice guy that he won't ever pull away or put her in her place.

Except that George also happens to be a schizophrenic with a second personality, a personality that has only one goal in life: to calmly, without any fuss, kill Netta Longdon. And then go to live in Maidenhead. (7/10)