Monday, March 03, 2008

Films: Lady in the water


After a fantastic debut with The sixth sense M. Night Shyamalan's films have become progressively cornier, but I've still enjoyed them all. Even The Village worked for me, despite the faintly ridiculous 'monsters' and an easily guessable twist ending. So I was quite surprised to discover that his latest film, Lady in the water is quite honestly one of the worst movies I've ever seen. It's not bad in a kitch way though, it's absolutly dead-pan serious and utterly, utterly laughable. There's nothing wrong with the acting, the effects are fine, the cinematography is decent enough... but the script really is I-can't-believe-they-just-said-that bad. Don't watch it. Not even out of curiosity. Just don't. (2/10)

Saturday, March 01, 2008

Books: Black Swan Green


David Mitchell's last novel was Cloud atlas, a magnum opus spanning centuries and genres and lives, a fireworks display of a book. By the second or third chapter of Black Swan Green one realises, perhaps with something of a sinking feeling, that Mitchell hasn't attempted anything nearly so ambitious this time around. This is the simplest of stories: a year in the life of a 13-year-old boy, Jason Taylor, growing up in England in the early Eighties, a year that marks a turning point of sorts between Jason's childhood and the rest of his life.

But what is lost here, in terms of scale and ballsiness, is more than made up for by the sheer brilliance of the storytelling. The first thing that hits you is how rich and detailed and hilarious is Mitchell's recreation of 1982. God knows how he remembers so clearly the teenage slang, or skewers so perfectly the middle class, Daily Mail-reading pomposity of the time. For anyone who has any acquaintance with that decade, reading this is like wallowing in nostalgia, and it's great.

Of course, a skillful pastiche is never going to be enough, in itself, to make for a fantastic read. The real revelation of Black Swan Green is its power to tug on the heart. The emotions of the story sneak up on you, building in intensity to a conclusion that made me cry. This isn't just a book about adolescence; the realisations Jason comes to, and the changes he makes in his life, should have meaning for us all. It is a book about courage and about the power of words, and Mitchell shows that by just putting down the the right words, one after another, it is possible to create a beautiful, simple, profoundly moving experience. (10/10)

Saturday, February 23, 2008

Films: There will be blood


Two things had built my expectations about Paul Thomas Anderson's There will be blood to dizzying heights. Firstly, the unanimously glowing reviews from Mark Kermode to the staff of Ain't It Cool News and everyone in between. Not just glowing, but positively gushing, with claims that the film "reinvents the language of cinema" coming from multiple quarters. The second contributing factor was my own love of Anderson's previous work. Boogie nights is a great film, but Magnolia and Punch-drunk love are two of my favourites of all time. So to say that I was looking forward to There will be blood is something of an understatement.

Perhaps it's not all that surprising, then, that I was disappointed. The melancholy but hopeful P.T. Anderson of Magnolia and Punch-drunk love is simply nowhere to be found in this new film, about an American oil prospector who starts out dour and standoffish and becomes more unpleasant the richer he gets. This is a film chock full of themes; it's about family and loyalty and an America founded on oil, religion, money and blood. Daniel Day-Lewis gives a mesmerising performance in the central role, and the film is strikingly photographed, so there's plenty to like. But there's nothing groundbreaking in it, that I can see, just a decent film, lacking the heart, the surprises, the humour, and the surrealism that one might hope for from such a great director. (7/10)

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Films: Shirley Valentine


This is a film that completely took me by surprise. The eponymous heroine of Shirley Valentine (d. Lewis Gilbert) is a bored housewife in Liverpool, cooking dinner for her ungrateful husband, ready for 6 o'clock, on the dot, every day. Reminiscing about her disappointing life so far leads Shirley to take up the offer from a friend of a week's vacation in Greece, much to the astonishment and disgust of her husband.

The film was made, and is set, in the eighties, portraying what feels like a turning point in British social history, when the constrained roles that most working-class women had put up with for centuries began to butt up against the modern world. And it's a cliche to say it, but the truth is that they just don't make films like this any more. As laugh-out-loud funny, but more bitter and much more real, than The full monty; as authentic as Mike Leigh's work, but much wittier, Shirley Valentine isn't quite like anything else I've seen. (7/10)

Monday, February 18, 2008

Films: The squid and the whale


The squid and the whale (d. Noah Baumbach) follows the break-up of two New York intellectuals, a guy whose promising literary career stalled many years ago, and his wife, who is in her ascendency. This feels like very well-trodden ground - Wonder boys is one of many similar films - although here we see everything from the point of view of the couple's two teenage sons, as they struggle to understand and deal with the divorce. All in all it's pretty good. The father is predictably egotistical, with few redeeming features, and the wife comes out very well. It would be so refreshing one day to see a story like this where the man in the relationship is the more likeable of the two. Anyway, the sons are interesting, and the film is well-acted all round, with a sharp script that ends on just the right note of catharsis. (6/10)

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Books: Papillon


Four months after I began it, I finally finished reading Papillon (Henri Charriere). This story of a Frenchman sentenced to life imprisonment in the penal colonies of South America is not dull, or uninteresting, by any means. Many of Papillon's anecdotes and escape attempts make for good reading, and paint a picture of a man living by a code of honour, determined to keep fighting for his freedom if it takes forever.

The problem, for me, was the lack of any sense of progression or structure, the absence of plot threads or character journeys weaving together towards a climax, the complete aimlessness of the book.
Papillon gets captured. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon manages to escape.
Papillon gets captured. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon attempts to escape. Papillon manages to escape.
Papillon gets captured....
There are elements within this memoir that are memorable and reasonably well written, but without an overarching plot or a cast of characters it's too easy to put the book down and not pick it up again for weeks. (5/10)

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Films: The lives of others


The lives of others (d. Florian Henckel-Donnersmark) is a German film, set in East Berlin during the Cold War, about the Stasi's attempts to root out traitors to the Communist cause. A highly efficient and committed Stasi officer is assigned to bug a prominent playwrite and his actor girlfriend in order to find evidence of sedition, all three of whom are played beautifully. The officer is particularly memorable; at first ruthless and impassive, his character develops in ways that are complex and tragic. The plot twists and turns like the best thrillers, but concludes with an understated and very moving denument. (8/10)

Friday, February 08, 2008

Books: Neverwhere


Neil Gaiman is something of a legend in certain circles, having revolutionised the comic book medium in the late eighties with his epic, adult, genre-spanning series, The Sandman. Since then he has moved on to novels, children's books, television, and most recently films, with Mirrormask, Stardust and Beowulf. Gaiman's strength is to take an encyclopaedic knowledge of myth, religion and folklore and mash it up against the mundanities of modern life. Often funny, but always grand and dishevelled in equal measure, he remains one of my favourite authors.

Having said all of that, Neverwhere, Gaiman's first novel, is one of his weaker stories. The concept, as always, is inventive and magical, the idea that on the rooftops of London, and beneath its streets and buildings, there exists a parallel world, populated by those who have dropped off the radar of polite society. The homeless and the destitute rub shoulders with rat-speakers, fishermen trawling the sewers for treasure, as well as an order of black friars, seven spooky sisters, an earl in his court, and an angel called Islington.

The problem is that the execution of this idea comes across as rather amateurish. The lack of subtlety suggests a book aimed at teenagers, and there's a horrible feeling of authorial smugness, a clever-clever kind of humour that irritates as much as it entertains. The central character is so utterly dense that you soon find yourself wanting to shake some sense into him, and the plot is pretty much your standard 'quest for the grail'. Despite these problems, there is still a lot to like; particularly the attention to detail in a fully fleshed out alternate world, and a couple of memorable, and really nasty, villains. (7/10)

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Films: Sweeney Todd


Tim Burton has a wonderfully apealing visual style, for anyone attracted to the gothic, the baroque or the macabre, a style which suits the rat-infested streets of 19th Century London perfectly. Unfortunately, Burton's sumptuous visual treats only rarely make it all the way to becoming truly great movies, and Sweeney Todd: The demon barber of Fleet Street is one that didn't quite work for me. Johnny Depp's performance in the title role is really, really good, blending theatricality with pathos, and he's ably supported by Helena Bonham-Carter, Alan Rickman and others. The problem, for me, was the grating, discordant, but thankfully very forgetable, music, by Sondheim. This is the sort of stuff that puts people off musical theatre completely, and it almost ruins what could have been Burton's best film in years. (6/10)

Monday, January 28, 2008

Books: Mesopotamia: writing, reasoning and the gods


Mesopotamia: writing, reasoning and the gods (Jean Bottero) avoids discussion of the political or social history of the region entirely, and concentrates its focus on the way the people of Sumer and Akkad thought. By analysing the development of language and exploring a number of surviving literary works Bottero attempts to convey just how alien this ancient civilization was to our own. But even while stressing the impossibility of transposing our own values and viewpoints to the ancient past, the book also examines the ways in which this cradle of Western civilization has influenced our present. The book is fascinating, and the author's enthusiasm comes across on every page, unashamedly advocating academic inquiry and the acquisition of useless knowledge for its own sake. (7/10)

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Films: The consequences of love


The consequences of love (d. Paolo Sorrentino) is a slow, stylish Italian film. It's a beautifully shot, intriguing mystery about a shy middle-aged man who lives in a nice hotel and shuns human contact. Like a conjuring trick, the film is at its most powerful while its secrets remain hidden; the answers lack the inventiveness that one hopes for. Certainly worth a look, though, as an unusual examination of the consequences of new love after years of loneliness and isolation. (6/10)

Thursday, January 03, 2008

Films: Death at a funeral


Death at a funeral (d. Frank Oz) is an English comedy that isn't nearly as funny as it thinks it is. Various "quirky" characters assemble for a funeral but things go off the rails thanks to some accidental drug-taking, a blackmailing dwarf, and a grumpy old codger. The plot is derivative of many superior movies, the music and the acting have the subtlety of a mallet, but most importantly, the script is almost completely devoid of laughs. (3/10)

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Books: The face of another


I can't find much to say about The face of another (Kobo Abe), except that reading it was a chore. Unpleasant and completly uninvolving, the novel takes a potentially interesting plot about a man constructing a life-like mask to disguise his disfigured face, and saps all the life out of it. There is almost no plot - chuck in a distant wife and a rape fantasy and I've pretty much described the whole book in two sentences - instead, what fills this tedious tome is page after page of internal monologue, analysing what it means to have a face in teeth-grindingly minute detail. (1/10)

Friday, December 28, 2007

Films: Once


Once (d. John Carney) is a simple, low-budget film about an Irish busker and a young émigré from Eastern Europe. The two meet, form a bond, and eventually form a band, in a story that reminded me of Lost in translation. Long, uninterupted musical interludes frame a bittersweet account of unexpected companionship, thwarted by the realities and complexities of life. (8/10)

Saturday, December 15, 2007

Films: The graduate

The graduate (d. Mike Nichols) made the name of the young Dustin Hoffman, and it's easy to see why. He's excellent as the naive, awkward, hesitant university graduate who gets in too deep with an older woman and comes to regret it. Anne Bancroft plays the icy temptress, whose no-nonsense attitude towards her young lover leads to many very funny scenes but eventually turns to scorn. (7/10)

Monday, December 10, 2007

Books: If I told you once


If I told you once (Judy Budnitz) tells the story of four generations of women from a Jewish family originating somewhere in Eastern Europe that emigrates to the US early in the 20th Century. There is an undercurrent of gothic fantasy throughout, particularly in the early sections which are populated by wolves and woodcutters, sinister crones and pale maidens with flowing hair. But the young heroine of these first chapters escapes to New York and begins to mature as we watch her daughter, grand-daughter and great grand-daughter grow to adulthood.

All of these girls begin as very sympathetic characters, but as they grow older something seems to go wrong and negative, even villainous traits emerge. The reader can identify with and cheer on the youngest girl of the family, up until the point where the next youngest comes along. In the New World the goings-on become more realistic, and sadly, a little more dull. There are still flashes of the bizarre: street sweepers who come in the night and take everything away; an ice-cream man who abducts small children; but on the whole the world becomes more mundane. Overall, some lovely, sinister, beautifully written flights of fancy, are undercut slightly by a plot without rhythm or crescendo that circles round and goes nowhere. (7/10)

Tuesday, December 04, 2007

TV: The Sopranos, Season 6 (Part 2)


See my previous post for how much I love The Sopranos. The last nine episodes have drawn a lot of criticism, particularly for the ambiguous resolution (or non-resolution) of Tony Soprano's story. I was crossing my fingers that I wouldn't feel similarly let down, but I have to admit that in the end it wasn't quite all I'd hoped for.

The end of the final episode, to me, was pretty perfect, and shouldn't come as a nasty surprise to anyone who's been watching the show from the start. But those last few episodes, which wrap up some storylines beautifully (Tony's son AJ and his nephew Chris both have fitting send offs), really failed to deliver in other ways. The biggest let-down was the underutlization of Edie Falco as Carmella Soprano. To waste such a talented actor, and a character with so many skeletons still to unearth, is a terrible shame. But a couple of dud episodes and some wasted potential can't do much to dent this series that has put more intelligence and depth into television than any other. (9/10)

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Films: Beowulf


Neil Gaiman's screenplay for Beowulf (d. Robert Zemeckis) hits all the right buttons. The plot is exciting and unfolds like clock-work, with the early defeat of the gruesome, pathetic monster Grendel making way for more challenging foes and the best dragon in screen history. The dialogue is fun and there's just the right note of poignancy, come the end. Unfotunately, the strange computer-animation-over-actors medium is distancing and distracting, and the shots are too often taken from crazy angles, simply to make the 3D effects look good. All in all, a good film but not half as good as it would have been in live action. (6/10)

Saturday, November 24, 2007

Films: Double indemnity


Yet another film about an unsatisfied woman plotting to kill off her husband for the insurance payout; seemingly the default plot for American movies from the 1940s. Double indemnity (d. Billy Wilder) makes great use of the black-and-white medium, with some striking shots, full of light and shadow, which clearly inspired the Coen's much later The man who wasn't there. And the idea to view the story from the insurance salesmen's perspective is an interesting twist. I just wish the film-maker's of the time could have come up with some more original, and less misogynist, stories. (7/10)

Friday, November 23, 2007

Films: The Maltese Falcon


In The Maltese Falcon (d. John Huston), Humphrey Bogart plays Sam Spade, a private detective unwillingly drawn into a plot to smuggle a priceless antiquity into the country. Spade is likeable, a charismatic man who's out of his depth but always manages to gain the upper hand, and the story is well put-together. The supporting actors are generaly very entertaining (Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre would both team up with Bogart again for Casablanca), but unfortunately there is zero chemistry between Bogart and his leading lady, which gives the film a rather shaky foundation. (6/10)

Sunday, November 18, 2007

Films: Babel


Not very much happens in Babel (d. Alejandrao Gonzalez Inarritu). There is a story about a Japanese girl trying to deal with the suicide of her mother, which is beautifully filmed (actually it's all beautifully filmed) but very short on plot development. This coincides with the tales of an American woman who is accidentally shot on a tour bus in Morocco and the woman's au pair taking the children into Mexico for a family wedding. Extended slow-motion scenes with the dialogue taken out lend the film an ethereal quality at first but eventually become tiresome. Not a patch on Inarritu's incredible Amores Perros. (6/10)

Thursday, November 15, 2007

TV: Battlestar Galactica, Season 2


The new Battlestar Galactica is still taking itself a bit too seriously in Season 2, but this is the only complaint to be made about an otherwise fantastic series. The slow pace of the first season is done away with as cliffhanger follows cliffhanger, rivalling 24 for intensity, and the story of a decimated remnant of humanity fleeing across space from their relentless mechanoid pursuers develops in shading and depth. As the fleet deals with paranoia and division within its own ranks, and the Cylon enemies begin to show misgivings about their genocidal actions, the distinction between friend and foe becomes blurred. (8/10)

Monday, November 12, 2007

Films: Good bye, Lenin!


A sympathetic woman, devoted to the ruling Socialist Party in East Berlin witnesses her son demonstrating against the communist leadership and her heart stops; she falls into a coma. When Christiane awakens nine months later the doctor advises that another shock could kill her, and so her children decide to disguise the terrible truth, that the wall has fallen and the capitalists have moved in.

The set-up for Good bye, Lenin! (d. Wolfgang Becker) could have been played solely for laughs, and it certainly is a funny film, but it's also surprisingly moving. Innocent romance, filial devotion, aspirational beliefs, and an estranged father make for a sweet, tart, smile-inducing experience. (10/10)

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Comics: Fables, Vol. 4: March of the wooden soldiers


The Fables series takes another leap forward with Vol. 4: March of the wooden soldiers (Bill Willingham), a story that begins with espionage and politicing and concludes with all-out war against the mysterious 'Adversary'. The large and growing cast of fairytale characters allows Willingham to continue to increase the complexity, both in terms of plot and characterisation, and the pacing is spot on. (Not to mention the lovely, quirky artwork). This is quickly becoming a favourite. (9/10)

Friday, November 09, 2007

Books: The left hand of darkness


The left hand of darkness (Ursula LeGuin) is classic 60s science fiction about a man sent to a new world in order to convince its inhabitants to join an interplanetary alliance. These inhabitants are similar to humans in every way except one: they are without gender. The people are androgynous for three weeks out of every month, randomly developing into males or females for a few days in order to reproduce.

This conceit allows LeGuin to examine gender relations in the real world, by comparison with a world in which they are meaningless, or at least, it should do. In fact the amount of real insight in the book is disapointingly slim, with far more attention given to the world's wintery climate and a death-defying journey across the frozen wasteland. There are occasional flashes of brilliant prose, surrounded by much that is simply workmanlike, even leaden. The style is quite obscure at times, perhaps an attempt to simulate the culture shock felt by the narrator.

Overall, a very interesting idea, but a hit-and-miss novel. (6/10)