
Neil Gaiman is something of a legend in certain circles, having revolutionised the comic book medium in the late eighties with his epic, adult, genre-spanning series,
The Sandman. Since then he has moved on to novels, children's books, television, and most recently films, with
Mirrormask,
Stardust and
Beowulf. Gaiman's strength is to take an encyclopaedic knowledge of myth, religion and folklore and mash it up against the mundanities of modern life. Often funny, but always grand and dishevelled in equal measure, he remains one of my favourite authors.
Having said all of that,
Neverwhere, Gaiman's first novel, is one of his weaker stories. The concept, as always, is inventive and magical, the idea that on the rooftops of London, and beneath its streets and buildings, there exists a parallel world, populated by those who have dropped off the radar of polite society. The homeless and the destitute rub shoulders with rat-speakers, fishermen trawling the sewers for treasure, as well as an order of black friars, seven spooky sisters, an earl in his court, and an angel called Islington.
The problem is that the execution of this idea comes across as rather amateurish. The lack of subtlety suggests a book aimed at teenagers, and there's a horrible feeling of authorial smugness, a clever-clever kind of humour that irritates as much as it entertains. The central character is so utterly dense that you soon find yourself wanting to shake some sense into him, and the plot is pretty much your standard 'quest for the grail'. Despite these problems, there is still a lot to like; particularly the attention to detail in a fully fleshed out alternate world, and a couple of memorable, and really nasty, villains. (7/10)