
If I told you once (Judy Budnitz) tells the story of four generations of women from a Jewish family originating somewhere in Eastern Europe that emigrates to the US early in the 20th Century. There is an undercurrent of gothic fantasy throughout, particularly in the early sections which are populated by wolves and woodcutters, sinister crones and pale maidens with flowing hair. But the young heroine of these first chapters escapes to New York and begins to mature as we watch her daughter, grand-daughter and great grand-daughter grow to adulthood.
All of these girls begin as very sympathetic characters, but as they grow older something seems to go wrong and negative, even villainous traits emerge. The reader can identify with and cheer on the youngest girl of the family, up until the point where the next youngest comes along. In the New World the goings-on become more realistic, and sadly, a little more dull. There are still flashes of the bizarre: street sweepers who come in the night and take everything away; an ice-cream man who abducts small children; but on the whole the world becomes more mundane. Overall, some lovely, sinister, beautifully written flights of fancy, are undercut slightly by a plot without rhythm or crescendo that circles round and goes nowhere. (7/10)








































































































































